Comparing cases to find the principle
Shown that comparing two or more cases side by side helps people learn the principle they share better than studying cases one at a time.
The numbers and sources
- Effect
- Across 336 tests in 57 experiments, case comparison led to more learning than sequential or single cases, unrelated cases, and traditional instruction, d = .50. Effects were larger when learners looked for similarities between the cases and when a principle was given after the comparison [3].
- Population
- 57 experiments in laboratory and classroom settings [3].
- Caveats
- Effects were larger on immediate tests than on delayed ones [3]. Comparing cases is one route to principles. It is not "first-principles thinking" as popular writing uses the term.