07 / 08Think

Write to find out

A question has sat in the back of the mind for a week: whether to change jobs, what a chapter was really arguing, why a project keeps slipping. Thinking about it goes in circles, and the same three thoughts come round again. Writing them down changes that. On paper the first thought has to become a sentence. The second has to follow from it, or visibly fail to. In a class it happens in the short response written before a discussion, or the paragraph that shows which part of the reading didn't make sense. At work it happens in the memo drafted to find out what the recommendation actually is. This lesson uses writing to find a view, before writing is used to present one.

In five minutesSet a timer for five minutes. At the top of a page, write one question you keep circling. Write without stopping until the timer ends, then underline the one sentence that says most clearly what you think.

Method · Writing to learn  /  Skill · Explain  /  Writing · Teaching

↺From last time · First principles, and working backward

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why mark each assumption as checked or borrowed?

Most plans copy earlier ones, and the copied parts are rarely tested. Marking them shows which parts rest on evidence and which rest on habit, so you know what to check before rebuilding.

Why work backward from the goal instead of forward from today?

Forward planning asks what could be done first, and there are many options. Backward planning asks what must be true just before the goal, which narrows each step until it reaches something doable now.

What does asking how to guarantee failure add?

Ways to fail are often easier to name than ways to succeed. Listing them turns vague risk into specific causes, and you can check the plan against each one.

01Where it comes from

Michel de Montaigne called his books Essais, first published in 1580, from the French for trials or attempts. He wrote them to test his own judgment on whatever came up, including subjects he did not know well (see Voices). In 1977 the composition scholar Janet Emig argued that writing is a unique mode of learning [1]. Peter Elbow's Writing Without Teachers (1973) taught freewriting: writing without stopping for a set time, without going back to edit [2]. Researchers then measured writing to learn. Robert Bangert-Drowns and colleagues pooled 48 school writing-to-learn programs in 2004 [3]. Steve Graham and colleagues pooled 56 experiments in science, social studies and math in 2020 [4]. A line often quoted about writing to find out what you think is credited to E. M. Forster, who said he was quoting someone else (see Misattributed).

Also called Writing to think, freewriting, the essay as an attempt, writing across the curriculum.

Sounding it at a distance

in these Essays I take hold of all occasions where, though it happen to be a subject I do not very well understand, I try, however, sounding it at a distance, and finding it too deep for my stature, I keep me on the shore

Michel de Montaigne, Essays, "Of Democritus and Heraclitus" Book I, chapter 50 · tr. Charles Cotton

Montaigne is explaining what his essays are. Each one is a trial of his judgment, made on any subject, including ones he doesn't know well. He wades in to see how deep the water is, and he counts knowing where to stop as part of the skill. The essay begins before the writer knows the answer. Writing to find out works the same way.

Read it in full

The book made me

I have no more made my book than my book has made me

Michel de Montaigne, Essays, "Of Giving the Lie" Book II, chapter 18 · tr. Charles Cotton

Montaigne asks whether his years of writing about himself were wasted if no one read them. He answers that the work shaped him. Setting his thoughts in order on the page made him order them in his head. He adds that writing kept his fancy from "losing itself and roving at random." The benefit he names comes to the writer first, and to the reader second.

Read it in full

02The method

Writing to learn

  1. Write the question at the top of the page, in one sentence.
  2. Put your notes away. Write for ten minutes without stopping. Don't edit. If you get stuck, write the question again and keep going.
  3. Read it back. Underline the one sentence that says most clearly what you think.
  4. Mark the places where the writing went vague, contradicted itself, or ran out. Those are your open questions.
  5. Check the marked places against your sources. Then write the view again, shorter, starting from the underlined sentence.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on A ten-minute freewrite on the Enchiridion, chapter 1, after reading it once

The question

Do I believe my reputation is "not in my power"?

Ten minutes, no notes

Epictetus says reputation is not in our power. That seems wrong at first because I work hard to be reliable and people notice. But then what people think is in their heads, not mine. I can be on time every day and someone can still decide I'm careless. So maybe what's mine is being reliable, and the reputation is a side effect that usually follows but doesn't have to. I don't know what he'd say about lying about yourself. That seems like trying to control the reputation directly. Also not sure if he means don't care about it or just don't count on it.

Clearest sentence

What's mine is being reliable. The reputation usually follows, but doesn't have to.

Where it went vague

  • "Don't care about it or don't count on it?" I don't know which he means.
  • Lying about yourself: I didn't finish the thought.

Shorter, from the clearest sentence

My reliability is in my power. My reputation follows it most of the time, but other people decide it. Epictetus says to work on the first and not to stake my peace on the second. Check: does the chapter say "don't care," or "don't count on"?

The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 20 minutes

For a class

After a lecture or a chapter, before reviewing anything, write for ten minutes on one question: what was the main argument, and do you believe it? No notes. Underline your clearest sentence and mark where you got stuck. Check those places in the text and write a five-sentence version. To practice on a hosted text, read Seneca's second chapter and write on whether his claim holds for your own week.

Open it in the reader: On the Shortness of Life and Other Dialogues, On the Shortness of Life, II

For work and life

Before a meeting where you have to recommend something, write for ten minutes on the question with no slides or notes: what should we do, and why? Underline the sentence that comes closest to an answer. Mark every place you hedged or skipped a step. Fill those gaps, then write the recommendation in three sentences and send it ahead of the meeting.

The blank page for this is in the Think workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Editing while drafting. Stopping to fix each sentence holds the writing at the first thought. Draft fast, and fix it afterward.
  • Writing from the notes. Copying notes into sentences is transcription. In one study, writing from memory beat note taking with the text at hand. Put the notes away first.
  • Treating the draft as the answer. The first pass finds a view. It doesn't check it. Go back to the sources for the marked places.
  • Long pieces, rarely. In the 2004 meta-analysis, longer writing assignments predicted smaller gains, while programs that ran longer predicted larger ones. Short pieces, written often, over weeks.
  • Writing only for a reader. A first draft written to impress skips the parts you're unsure of. Write the first one for yourself.

06Research

What research has measured

Writing about a subject to learn it

Shown that writing about course content improves learning by a small amount on average, across grades and subjects.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across 48 school programs, writing to learn had a small positive effect on academic achievement. Prompts to reflect on one's own understanding, and longer programs, predicted larger effects. Grades 6 to 8 and longer writing assignments predicted smaller ones [3]. Across 56 experiments in science, social studies and math, writing about content improved learning, effect size 0.30, about equally across subjects and school levels [4].
Population
48 school programs [3]. 56 experiments with students in grades 1 to 12 [4].
Caveats
Both reviews cover school students, not adults at work. The 2004 abstract does not give the pooled number [3]. The 2020 review found the type of writing activity did not change the effect [4].

Writing from memory

One study found that writing tasks requiring recall, such as an essay written from memory, beat note taking and highlighting on a later test.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Essay writing and free recall, which both required retrieval, led to better final test scores than note taking and highlighting. More essay-like responses went with better scores. Students skilled at building mental models of a narrative gained the most [5].
Population
One experiment comparing four tasks. The abstract does not give a count [5].
Caveats
One lab experiment. How much writing helped depended on individual differences [5].

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why write without stopping or editing?

Stopping to fix sentences keeps the writing near the first thought. Writing straight through forces the next sentence to follow from the last, and the places where it can't are what you need to know.

Why put the notes away before writing?

With notes open, the writing copies them. Writing from memory makes you pull the ideas out and arrange them yourself, and in the study, tasks that required that kind of recall led to better scores.

What are the marked vague places for?

They show where the understanding runs out. Those few places are what to check in the source, which saves rereading everything.

Sources
  1. Emig J. Writing as a mode of learning. College Composition and Communication. 1977;28(2):122-128. https://doi.org/10.2307/356095
  2. Elbow P. Writing Without Teachers. New York: Oxford University Press; 1973. Oxford University Press, 1973
  3. Bangert-Drowns RL, Hurley MM, Wilkinson B. The effects of school-based writing-to-learn interventions on academic achievement: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research. 2004;74(1):29-58. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543074001029
  4. Graham S, Kiuhara SA, MacKay M. The effects of writing on learning in science, social studies, and mathematics: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research. 2020;90(2):179-226. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654320914744
  5. Arnold KM, Umanath S, Thio K, Reilly WB, McDaniel MA, Marsh EJ. Understanding the cognitive processes involved in writing to learn. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied. 2017;23(2):115-127. https://doi.org/10.1037/xap0000119

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII