02 / 08Think

Define your terms

A team agrees to finish a project "soon." One person hears two weeks. Another hears the end of the quarter. A pharmacist says a side effect is "common," and the patient pictures one person in two. A study group argues for an hour about whether an author's argument is "fair," and finds out at the end that each person meant something different by the word. Many disagreements are about a word before they are about anything else. In a class it shows up in an essay prompt: "assess," "significant," "cause." At work it shows up in a goal everyone signed: "done," "customer," "on time." This lesson takes the one word an argument or a plan turns on and pins it down before the work starts.

In five minutesPick the one word your current task or argument depends on. Write one sentence saying what it means here, then one thing it includes and one thing it leaves out.

Method · Defining your terms  /  Philosophy · Law

↺From last time · Ask a better question

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why ask what a claim is being compared with?

A claim like "it works" or "it's behind" only means something next to a baseline: another diet, the planned date, doing nothing. Naming the comparison turns a vague claim into one that can be checked.

Why ask one more question of the first answer?

First answers are often vague but sound complete, as "The laws" did for Meletus. The second question asks for the specific person, number or case, and that is usually where the real gap shows.

Why write your own questions instead of reading the material again?

Writing a question makes you search the text and connect its parts to find what matters. In the studies, students who did this understood and recalled more than those who reread or reviewed notes.

01Where it comes from

Socrates often opened with the question "what is it?" In Plato's Euthyphro he asks a man prosecuting his own father what piety is, and turns down the first answer because it gives an example, not a definition (see Voices). Aristotle made a method of it. In the Topics a definition is "a phrase signifying a thing's essence," built from a genus, the wider kind a thing belongs to, and differentiae, the features that set it apart within that kind [1]. Law does the same work by drafting. Contracts commonly open with a definitions section. Federal law has one for all its statutes: 1 U.S.C. § 1 says that, unless the context indicates otherwise, "person" covers corporations, companies and other organizations as well as individuals [2]. Research has measured the cost of leaving a term loose mostly with words for chance and risk [3][4][5]. We found no study that tests defining terms as a method in itself.

Also called Definition by genus and difference, defined terms, the "what is it?" question, operational definitions.

An example is not a definition

Remember that I did not ask you to give me two or three examples of piety, but to explain the general idea which makes all pious things to be pious.

Socrates, in Plato, Euthyphro 6d · tr. Benjamin Jowett

Euthyphro is on his way to court to prosecute his own father, and he is sure he knows what piety requires. Asked what piety is, he says it is doing what he is doing. Socrates answers that this is one case, and asks what all pious acts share. The dialogue ends with no definition agreed. Euthyphro leaves still certain, still unable to say what the word means.

Read it in full

Genus first, then difference

the framer of a definition should first place the object in its genus, and then append its differences

Aristotle, Topics Book VI, chapter 1 · tr. W. A. Pickard-Cambridge

The Topics is a manual for debate, and Book VI lists ways to test a definition someone else has offered. This line is one of the tests. Has the definer named the right wider kind, and then said what sets the thing apart within it? Aristotle's stock example, from Book I, is man as "an animal that walks on two feet." The same two questions work on any word a plan or an argument depends on.

Read it in full

02The method

Defining your terms

  1. Find the word the question, plan or argument turns on. Write it at the top of a page.
  2. Write what it means here in one sentence: first the wider kind of thing it is, then what sets it apart from others of that kind.
  3. Test it on cases. List two things it should include and two it should leave out, and check that the definition sorts them correctly.
  4. Where you can, add a number or a test someone else could check: "Done means the client has signed off in writing."
  5. Share the definition before the argument or the plan begins, and ask whether others read the word the same way.
  6. Use the word only in that sense from then on. If the meaning has to change, say so and write the new one.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on The phrase "in our power" in the Enchiridion, chapter 1

What I'm explaining

"In our power," the term the whole chapter turns on.

Explained in plain words, to someone new to it

  • Wider kind: things that happen in a person's life.
  • What sets it apart: the ones that are a person's own act and can't be blocked by anyone else.
  • Includes: what I believe about an event, what I go after, what I try to avoid.
  • Leaves out: my body, my money, my reputation, my job title.

Where I got stuck or reached for jargon

  • My first try said "things I control." Too wide. I control my hand when I lift a cup, and Epictetus puts the body on the other list.
  • "Act" is doing a lot of work here.

What I looked up

Long's list: "opinion," "movement towards a thing," "desire, aversion," "turning from a thing." All of them happen in the mind. Lifting a cup is an act of the body, so it falls outside.

Explained again, shorter

In our power: what my own mind does (judging, wanting, avoiding), which no one else can stop.

The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 20 minutes

For a class

Take the key term in your next essay prompt or exam question: "assess," "cause," "significant," or the subject's own word, such as "market" or "cell." Fifteen minutes. Write a one-sentence definition with the wider kind and what sets it apart. List two examples it includes and two it leaves out. Then compare it with your textbook's definition and note where the two differ.

For work and life

Pick a goal or agreement that rests on one loose word: "done," "on time," "affordable," "healthy." Write what you mean by it in one sentence, with a number or a test if you can. Ask one other person to write theirs separately, without seeing yours. Compare the two, and agree on one wording before the next step.

The blank page for this is in the Think workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • An example for a definition. Euthyphro answered with one case of piety. A list of cases doesn't say what they share. Name the wider kind and what sets this one apart.
  • Too wide or too narrow. If the definition lets in what it should keep out, or the reverse, adjust it. Testing it on cases finds this quickly.
  • Defining a word with itself. "Fair means treating people fairly" moves nothing. Use other words.
  • Arguing over the label. Once both meanings are on the table, a disagreement about the label alone may not matter. Agree on one label and move to the real question.
  • Changing the meaning partway. A word that shifts sense mid-argument can make a weak step look strong. Hold it fixed, or flag the change.

06Research

What research has measured

Words for risk mean different things to different people

Shown that people turn the same word for risk, such as "rare" or "common," into very different numbers.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across 33 studies, average readings of "rare" ranged from 7 to 21%, and of "common" from 34 to 71%. In 9 of them, lay readings ran far above the meanings the European Commission set for drug labels. In 10 of 12 samples asked, most people preferred numbers, alone or with words [3]. In four studies of more than 750 people, word labels for side effects led to gross overestimates of risk compared with numbers [4]. Earlier lab work found large but stable differences between people in what terms such as "doubtful," "probable" and "likely" meant to them [5].
Population
33 studies of lay readers [3]. More than 750 people in four studies [4]. Two experiments [5].
Caveats
Most studies concern health risk, in English. Defining a word with a number was compared with leaving it as a word, not tested as a habit people practice [3][4].

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why does an example not count as a definition?

An example shows one case. It doesn't say what the cases share, so it can't sort a new one. A definition names the wider kind and what sets this thing apart, which lets anyone apply it.

Why test a definition on cases it should include and leave out?

A definition can sound right and still be too wide or too narrow. Checking it against two cases in and two out shows quickly whether it sorts things the way you meant.

Why add a number to a word like "soon" or "common"?

People read the same loose word as very different amounts, as the studies on "rare" and "common" show. A number or a test leaves less room for each person to hear their own meaning.

Sources
  1. Aristotle. Topics. Translated by W. A. Pickard-Cambridge. Oxford: Clarendon Press; 1928. Book I, chapter 5. https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/topics.1.i.html
  2. 1 U.S.C. § 1. Words denoting number, gender, and so forth. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/1/1
  3. Andreadis K, Chan E, Park M, et al. Imprecision and preferences in interpretation of verbal probabilities in health: A systematic review. Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2021;36(12):3820-3829. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-021-07050-7
  4. Berry DC, Knapp P, Raynor DK. Provision of information about drug side-effects to patients. The Lancet. 2002;359(9309):853-854. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(02)07923-0
  5. Wallsten TS, Budescu DV, Rapoport A, Zwick R, Forsyth B. Measuring the vague meanings of probability terms. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 1986;115(4):348-365. https://doi.org/10.1037/0096-3445.115.4.348

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII