Considering the opposite
Shown that asking people to list reasons they might be wrong makes their confidence more accurate and reduces one-sided weighing of evidence.
The numbers and sources
- Effect
- People who listed reasons for and against each answer before choosing gave more appropriate confidence judgments. When asked for just one reason, only a reason against the chosen answer helped. A supporting reason did not [2]. In two experiments, instructions to consider the opposite reduced bias in weighing new evidence and in testing first impressions of people, and worked better than instructions to be fair and unbiased [3].
- Population
- Two experiments in each paper [2][3]. The abstracts do not give participant counts.
- Caveats
- Lab tasks, measured on the spot. Neither paper followed people into later real decisions [2][3].