04 / 08Think

The other side at its strongest

Two people disagree about whether to buy or rent, whether a study method is worth the time, or whether a team should switch software. Each can describe the other's view. Each description tends to be the weakest version, the one that is easy to answer. In a class it shows up in an essay that brings in a counterargument only to knock it down in one sentence. At work it shows up in a meeting where the rival proposal is summarized by its critic. Answering the weak version feels like winning. It leaves the strong version untouched, and the people who hold it unconvinced. This lesson builds the other side at its best first, as its own holders would put it, and only then answers it.

In five minutesPick one view you disagree with. Write its best argument in three sentences, the way someone who holds it would put it. Then write one point in it you agree with.

Method · Steelmanning  /  Philosophy · Research psychology

↺From last time · What would change my mind?

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why write down what would change your mind before looking at the evidence?

Once a result arrives, it is easy to decide it doesn't count. A test written in advance fixes what counts as evidence against the belief, so the result can't be explained away after the fact.

Why does a reason against your answer help more than a reason for it?

Confidence rests on the evidence that comes to mind, and supporting reasons come easily. A reason against brings in what was left out, so the confidence matches the full picture better.

Why move a percentage in steps instead of switching all at once?

Most single results are noisy. A step keeps the earlier evidence in the count, and lets a run of results move the belief further than any one could.

01Where it comes from

John Stuart Mill set out the idea in On Liberty (1859). On disputed questions, he argued, the truth depends on a balance between two sets of reasons, and someone who knows only one side has no ground for preferring it (see Voices). He credits the habit to Cicero, who studied his opponent's case as hard as his own. In Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking (2013), the philosopher Daniel Dennett gave four rules he credits to the game theorist Anatol Rapoport. Restate the other view so well that its holder wishes they had put it that way. List the points of agreement. Mention anything you learned from it. Only then criticize [1]. "Steelmanning," the opposite of attacking a straw man, is a later informal name for the same practice. Psychologists study the pull toward one's own side under the name myside bias [2].

Also called Rapoport's rules, the strongest case, arguing the other side, myside bias.

Knowing only one side

He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that. His reasons may be good, and no one may have been able to refute them. But if he is equally unable to refute the reasons on the opposite side; if he does not so much as know what they are, he has no ground for preferring either opinion.

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion. Fourth edition, Longmans, 1869

Mill is arguing for free discussion, and says hearing opposing views is how anyone comes to understand their own. In mathematics all the argument sits on one side. On questions of conduct and everyday life, he says, three-fourths of the case for any view lies in answering the other. Without that, the reasonable position is to suspend judgment. The passage asks for knowledge of the other side's reasons, not agreement with them.

Read it in full

In their most persuasive form

He must be able to hear them from persons who actually believe them; who defend them in earnest, and do their very utmost for them. He must know them in their most plausible and persuasive form

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty Chapter 2, Of the Liberty of Thought and Discussion. Fourth edition, Longmans, 1869

A line earlier Mill says that hearing the other side from one's own teachers is not enough, because they present it with the refutation attached. He wants it from people who believe it. A few sentences on, he adds that if no opponents exist, they should be imagined and given "the strongest arguments which the most skilful devil's advocate can conjure up." Written in 1859, it is the method of this lesson.

Read it in full

02The method

Steelmanning

  1. Write the question both sides are answering, in neutral words both would accept.
  2. Write the other side's case at its strongest: its best evidence and best reasons, in the words its holders use. Draw on their sources, not their critics'.
  3. Check it. Show it to someone who holds that view, or compare it with their own writing, and fix it until they would sign it.
  4. List what you agree with, and anything you learned from that side.
  5. Only then write your reply, to the strong version.
  6. Note what would move you toward their side.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on A team decision: replace the weekly status meeting with written updates

The question

Should our team of eight replace the Monday status meeting with written updates?

What I think, and why

  • Yes. The meeting takes an hour, so eight people lose eight hours a week.
  • Most updates don't concern most people in the room.
  • Written updates can be read in five minutes, at any time.

The other side at its strongest

  • The meeting is the one time the whole team hears the same thing at once. Problems that touch two people's work come out because both are in the room.
  • Written updates get skimmed, or skipped. A blocked task can sit unseen for a week.
  • New members learn how the team thinks by listening.
  • Agree: blockers get caught in the meeting. Learned: two of last month's fixes started there.

What would change my mind

  • If a month of written updates misses a blocker the meeting would have caught. Compromise to test: written updates, plus a 15-minute call for blockers only.

04Try it · 25 minutes

For a class

Take an essay or seminar question with two serious positions. Twenty minutes. On one side of a page, write your view and its reasons. On the other, write the opposing view at its strongest, drawn from a source by someone who holds it. List two points you agree with. Then write your reply to the strong version in one paragraph, and compare it with the counterargument you would have written before.

For work and life

Before a meeting where two options compete, a vendor, a hire, a schedule, write the case for the option you don't favor as its best advocate would. Fifteen minutes. Read it to that advocate, or to someone who leans their way, and ask what you missed. Then list where you agree, and write your reply to the case they recognize.

The blank page for this is in the Think workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • A straw man with better manners. A polite summary of a weak version is still a weak version. Test yours on someone who holds the view.
  • Building it from critics. A case assembled from its opponents' quotes will be the version they found easiest to beat. Use the side's own sources.
  • Agreeing with everything. Stating a view at its best is not adopting it. Once it is strong, answer it.
  • Skipping the points of agreement. Without them, the reply reads as an attack, and the other side stops listening. Say them first.
  • Only on small questions. The habit is easy where little is at stake. The views held hardest benefit most from it.

06Research

What research has measured

Favoring your own side

Shown that how strongly people favor their own side when weighing evidence is only weakly linked with intelligence.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across a wide range of myside bias tasks, in which people evaluate evidence, generate arguments and test hypotheses, the size of the bias showed very little relation to intelligence. The authors conclude that avoiding it is a thinking skill intelligence tests don't measure [2].
Population
A review of many myside bias studies. The abstract does not give counts [2].
Caveats
A short review of correlational studies, written by the group behind many of them [2].

Asking for the other side

Early studies suggest that asking writers to research both sides, or to include counterarguments, leads them to use more of the other side.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Students given specific goals to include counterarguments and rebuttals wrote more of both than students without those goals. Instructions to persuade reduced counterarguments [3]. Balanced research instructions increased the use of other-side information in essays. A short text challenging the idea that good arguments are only facts reduced myside bias in stronger arguers and increased it in weaker ones [4].
Population
184 undergraduates writing argument essays [3]. 86 and 84 participants in two experiments [4].
Caveats
Lab writing tasks. More counterarguments on the page does not show they were weighed fairly [3][4].

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why answer the strongest version of a view and not the one most people state?

Beating a weak version leaves the strong one standing, and its holders unpersuaded. A reply that survives the best case is worth more, and you learn what the view actually gets right.

Why check your version with someone who holds the view?

A version built from the outside often misses the reason that matters most to its holders. If they would sign it, you have their case. If not, they will tell you what's missing.

Why does being smart not protect against favoring your own side?

In the studies, myside bias had little relation to intelligence. Skill at arguing can build a better case for what you already think. Practice at stating the other side is a separate habit.

Sources
  1. Dennett DC. Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking. New York: W. W. Norton; 2013. W. W. Norton, 2013
  2. Stanovich KE, West RF, Toplak ME. Myside bias, rational thinking, and intelligence. Current Directions in Psychological Science. 2013;22(4):259-264. https://doi.org/10.1177/0963721413480174
  3. Nussbaum EM, Kardash CM. The effects of goal instructions and text on the generation of counterarguments during writing. Journal of Educational Psychology. 2005;97(2):157-169. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.97.2.157
  4. Wolfe CR, Britt MA. The locus of the myside bias in written argumentation. Thinking & Reasoning. 2008;14(1):1-27. https://doi.org/10.1080/13546780701527674

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII