Misjudging what builds up
Shown that well-educated adults often misjudge how a stock changes, assuming it follows the shape of its inflow instead of tracking inflow minus outflow.
The numbers and sources
- Effect
- Given a graph of people entering and leaving a store, 96% and 95% correctly picked when the most people entered and left. Only 44% and 31% correctly picked when the most and the fewest were inside. Many assumed the crowd peaked when the net inflow peaked. Poor scores held up when the researchers changed the graphs, the context and the motivation [5]. In an earlier set of bathtub tasks, average scores were 77% on the simplest task and 48% on a slightly harder one [4].
- Population
- 173 graduate students, mostly MBA students, at MIT's Sloan School in the store study's first experiment, with more experiments after it [5]. Sloan graduate students in groups of 143 to 225 in the bathtub study [4].
- Caveats
- Most participants were graduate students at one business school, with strong mathematics training. These were paper tasks. They show how people read stocks and flows, not how they manage real savings or real sleep.