04 / 08Systems

Feedback loops

A savings account, a pile of unread articles and a week of short nights work the same way. Each is a quantity that builds up or drains. Each changes only through what flows in and what flows out. A paycheck flows in and rent flows out. New articles arrive and finished ones leave. Short nights add to sleep debt and long ones pay it down. Then come the loops. A larger balance earns more interest, which makes the balance larger still. A growing reading pile can make starting feel pointless, which grows the pile. A tired afternoon brings a late coffee, a worse night and a more tired morning. This lesson draws one of these as stocks, flows and loops, to see what actually drives it.

In five minutesPick one thing that piles up: an inbox, laundry, a reading list. Write how much came in this week and how much went out. If more came in, the pile grew. Write one change to the outflow.

Method · Stocks, flows and feedback loops  /  Engineering · Business

↺From last time · Make it a checklist

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why leave the easy steps off a checklist?

A long list gets skimmed, and the lines that matter drown. A checklist holds the steps that are easy to skip and costly to miss. Skill and habit handle the rest.

What does the pause point do?

It fixes the moment the list gets read, so reading it becomes part of the routine. A list without a set moment gets read when someone remembers, which is rarely when it is needed.

Why did checklists help in some hospitals and not others?

Results tracked how the lists were used. In Michigan, units wrote their own and nurses could stop a procedure. In Ontario, adoption under a policy showed no significant change.

01Where it comes from

Jay Forrester was an engineer. He led Project Whirlwind, an early MIT digital computer, and invented magnetic core memory in 1949 [1]. In 1956 he joined what became MIT's Sloan School of Management. Studying the boom-and-bust cycle at a General Electric appliance factory, he built a simulation showing that the company's own management practices, not the market, caused the swings [1]. His book Industrial Dynamics (1961) set out system dynamics, which models a system as stocks, the flows that change them, and the feedback loops that set the flows. Four of his students used his ideas to write The Limits to Growth in 1972 [1]. Donella Meadows was its principal author [2]. Her Thinking in Systems, drafted before her death in 2001 and published in 2008, explains stocks, flows, reinforcing loops and balancing loops for general readers [3]. Later, John Sterman and colleagues at MIT tested how graduate students with strong mathematics training reason about stocks and flows [4][5].

Also called System dynamics, causal loop diagram, stock and flow diagram, reinforcing loop, balancing loop, bathtub thinking.

02The method

Stocks, flows and feedback loops

  1. Name the stock: one quantity that builds up or drains, such as savings, unread pages or sleep debt. Draw it as a box.
  2. Draw each inflow as an arrow into the box and each outflow as an arrow out. Give each a rate: "$200 a week in", "3 articles a day in".
  3. Ask what sets each flow. Where the size of the stock changes a flow, draw an arrow from the box back to that flow.
  4. Label each loop. R for reinforcing, where more leads to more. B for balancing, where more leads to less.
  5. Mark any delay on an arrow, where a change now shows up days or weeks later.
  6. Pick one flow to change. Write which way the stock will move, and how fast.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on A reading backlog in a semester-long history course

The thing that builds up or runs down

  • Unread pages for History 201. 180 pages behind on Sunday night.

What flows in

  • About 90 pages assigned a week.

What flows out

  • About 60 pages read a week, most of it on Sunday night.

What feeds back

  • R: the bigger the pile, the more a 20-minute session feels pointless, so less gets read. More behind, less read.
  • B: the bigger the pile, the more the Friday quiz looms, so Thursday reading jumps. This keeps the pile from running away.
  • Delay: quizzes come every two weeks, so the push from B arrives late.

The loop, in a sentence

  • The pile grows by 30 pages a week, and the R loop wins until a quiz forces a catch-up.
  • Change: 25 pages after each of the four class meetings makes the outflow 100. The pile shrinks by 10 a week, so 180 pages take 18 weeks.
  • Add 40 pages on Sundays for a month. The pile shrinks by 50 a week and clears in about four weeks.

04Try it · 20 minutes

For a class

Pick a course where work piles up: readings, problem sets, lab write-ups. Draw the backlog as a box. Write the inflow as assignments per week and the outflow as what you finish per week. Add one loop: what happens to the outflow as the box grows? Label it R or B. Then write the change that makes the outflow beat the inflow, and how many weeks the box takes to clear. About 20 minutes.

For work and life

Draw one stock from your own week: a savings balance, an inbox, sleep, a queue of requests at work. Put a number on each inflow and outflow. Find one loop that makes it grow or shrink faster, and one that holds it steady. Mark any delay. Write which flow you could change this week, and what the stock should look like a month from now.

The blank page for this is in the Systems workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Watching the flow, not the stock. Spending less than last month can still leave savings falling. The balance rises only when more flows in than out.
  • Expecting the stock to jump. A stock moves only as fast as its flows. A big pile takes weeks to drain, even after the flows change.
  • Drawing only one loop. Most stocks sit inside a reinforcing loop and a balancing loop at once. One loop alone predicts runaway growth, or a steady level that never comes.
  • Arrows without labels. A tangle of bare arrows looks like a system and explains nothing. Write the rate or the reason on every arrow.

06Research

What research has measured

Misjudging what builds up

Shown that well-educated adults often misjudge how a stock changes, assuming it follows the shape of its inflow instead of tracking inflow minus outflow.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Given a graph of people entering and leaving a store, 96% and 95% correctly picked when the most people entered and left. Only 44% and 31% correctly picked when the most and the fewest were inside. Many assumed the crowd peaked when the net inflow peaked. Poor scores held up when the researchers changed the graphs, the context and the motivation [5]. In an earlier set of bathtub tasks, average scores were 77% on the simplest task and 48% on a slightly harder one [4].
Population
173 graduate students, mostly MBA students, at MIT's Sloan School in the store study's first experiment, with more experiments after it [5]. Sloan graduate students in groups of 143 to 225 in the bathtub study [4].
Caveats
Most participants were graduate students at one business school, with strong mathematics training. These were paper tasks. They show how people read stocks and flows, not how they manage real savings or real sleep.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Can a stock rise while its inflow is falling?

Yes. A stock rises whenever the inflow is larger than the outflow, even while the inflow shrinks. Reading the stock from the shape of the flow is the common mistake.

What is the difference between a reinforcing loop and a balancing loop?

In a reinforcing loop, more leads to more, so change speeds up. In a balancing loop, more leads to less, so the stock gets pulled back toward a level.

Why mark delays on the map?

A change made now may show in the stock weeks later. With the delay unmarked, a change that works can look like a failure and get dropped too soon.

Sources
  1. MIT Sloan School of Management. Professor Emeritus Jay W. Forrester, digital computing and system dynamics pioneer, dies at 98. November 2016. https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/professor-emeritus-jay-w-forrester-digital-computing-and-system-dynamics-pioneer-dies-98
  2. Donella Meadows Project. Donella "Dana" Meadows. https://donellameadows.org/donella-meadows-legacy/donella-dana-meadows/
  3. Meadows DH. Thinking in Systems: A Primer. Wright D, ed. Chelsea Green; 2008. first edition
  4. Sweeney LB, Sterman JD. Bathtub dynamics: Initial results of a systems thinking inventory. System Dynamics Review. 2000;16(4):249-286. https://doi.org/10.1002/sdr.198
  5. Cronin MA, Gonzalez C, Sterman JD. Why don't well-educated adults understand accumulation? A challenge to researchers, educators, and citizens. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 2009;108(1):116-130. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.obhdp.2008.03.003

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII