05 / 08Systems

Then what?

A rule at work says every expense over $50 needs a manager's signature. Spending drops. So does the speed of every small purchase, and some people start splitting one $80 order into two $40 ones. A student starts a paper the night before it is due and finishes on time. The grade comes back fine, and the lesson carried into next semester is that the night before works. A household buys groceries in bulk to save money, and some of the bulk goes stale before anyone eats it. The first effect of a choice shows up fast. The later effects arrive slowly, land somewhere else, and get blamed on something else. Asking "then what?" after each effect follows the chain a few links further before the choice gets made.

In five minutesTake one choice you are making this week. Write its first effect. Ask "then what?" twice and write each answer. Then write one thing the choice will use up.

Method · Second-order thinking  /  Economics · Sociology

↺From last time · Feedback loops

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Can a stock rise while its inflow is falling?

Yes. A stock rises whenever the inflow is larger than the outflow, even while the inflow shrinks. Reading the stock from the shape of the flow is the common mistake.

What is the difference between a reinforcing loop and a balancing loop?

In a reinforcing loop, more leads to more, so change speeds up. In a balancing loop, more leads to less, so the stock gets pulled back toward a level.

Why mark delays on the map?

A change made now may show in the stock weeks later. With the delay unmarked, a change that works can look like a failure and get dropped too soon.

01Where it comes from

In July 1850 the French economist Frédéric Bastiat published a pamphlet, That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen, his last [1]. It opens with a shopkeeper's son who breaks a window. The glazier earns six francs, and everyone sees it. No one sees the shoes or the book the shopkeeper would have bought with the same six francs. In 1936 the sociologist Robert Merton published "The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action" [2]. He sorted the reasons people fail to foresee the results of what they do: limited knowledge, errors of judgment, an immediate interest that crowds out later effects, values that rule out looking further, and predictions that change what they predict once made public. The "cobra effect", a story of a cobra bounty in Delhi that led people to breed cobras, has no documented source. The German economist Horst Siebert named it in 2001 [3]. A documented case of the same pattern is a 1902 rat bounty in Hanoi, which led to rat farms in the suburbs [3][4].

Also called Second-order effects, consequence chain, unintended consequences, the seen and the unseen, knock-on effects.

Two teachers

Experience teaches effectually, but brutally. It makes us acquainted with all the effects of an action, by causing us to feel them; and we cannot fail to finish by knowing that fire burns, if we have burned ourselves. For this rough teacher, I should like, if possible, to substitute a more gentle one. I mean Foresight.

Frédéric Bastiat, That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen Introduction

Bastiat opens by saying that an act, a habit or a rule gives rise to a series of effects. Only the first is immediate and seen. The rest unfold later. He adds that the same holds in health and in habits, where the sweetest first result can bring the most bitter later ones. Experience teaches the later effects by making us live them. "Then what?" is his gentler teacher, foresight, written down.

Read it in full

The six francs

It is not seen that as our shopkeeper has spent six francs upon one thing, he cannot spend them upon another. It is not seen that if he had not had a window to replace, he would, perhaps, have replaced his old shoes, or added another book to his library.

Frédéric Bastiat, That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen Part I, "The Broken Window"

The onlookers console the shopkeeper by saying the glazier has to make a living too. Bastiat grants that the glazier's six francs are real. His point is the other purchase, the one that never happens and so leaves nothing to look at. Any household budget works this way. Money or an hour spent on one thing is a pair of shoes, or a book, not had.

Read it in full

02The method

Second-order thinking

  1. Write the choice in one line: "Start the essay the night before" or "Require sign-off on every expense over $50."
  2. Write the first effect, the one everyone expects.
  3. Ask "then what?" of that effect and write the answer. Ask again of the answer, three or four times.
  4. Beside each effect, note who or what it lands on, and when: this week, next month, next year.
  5. Ask what stops happening because of the choice: the money, time or attention it uses up.
  6. Read the whole chain, then decide. Keep the choice, change it, or add a step that heads off a later effect.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on A proposal at a small office: manager sign-off on every purchase over $50

The decision, and the date

  • Require manager sign-off on every purchase over $50. Proposed November 3.

What I expect to happen

  • First effect: fewer small purchases, and supply spending drops.
  • Then what? Requests queue for the manager. Orders that took a day now take three or four.
  • Then what? People split one $80 order into two $40 orders to skip the queue.
  • Then what? Total spending falls less than hoped, and the manager spends about two hours a week on approvals.
  • Unseen: those two hours come out of the manager's planning time.

Why

  • Each link follows from people taking the fastest route to what they need for their work.

What I'm unsure of

  • Whether splitting orders would really happen here, and how much a three-day wait slows real work.

A year from now it failed. The likeliest reasons

  • The queue slowed everyone down, and split orders kept spending flat.
  • Change to bring to the meeting: set the limit at $200 and review monthly totals by team.

04Try it · 20 minutes

For a class

Pick a study habit you are weighing: an all-nighter before an exam, recorded lectures in place of live ones, a study group. Write the first effect. Ask "then what?" four times and write each answer, with when it shows up. Then write what the choice uses up that could have gone elsewhere. Circle any effect that arrives after the grade is in. About 20 minutes.

For work and life

Take a rule or change on the table at work or at home: a new approval step, a cut to the household budget, a standing meeting moved to Monday mornings. Run the chain four links out. For each link, note who it lands on and when. Add the unseen cost: what stops happening. Bring the chain to the decision, with one small change that heads off the worst later effect.

The blank page for this is in the Systems workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Stopping at the first effect. The first effect is the one everyone already sees. The method earns its time on the second and third links.
  • Chains with no end. Past four or five links, guessing outruns knowing. Stop where you can no longer say why one effect follows from the last.
  • Only bad effects. Later effects can be good. A slower approval step may also catch duplicate orders. Write both kinds.
  • Forgetting the unseen. Bastiat's point was the shoes never bought. Ask what the money or the hour would have done otherwise.

06Research

What research has measured

Missing the delayed effects of your own choices

One study found that people running a simulated supply chain with delays overlooked the later effects of their own orders, and did far worse than they could have.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Participants managed a simulated distribution chain with several players, feedback and time delays between ordering and delivery. Their decisions together produced swings that diverged systematically from the best possible results. A model of their choices showed they were insensitive to the feedback from their own decisions to the system around them [5].
Population
Participants in a simulated inventory game. The abstract does not give the number [5].
Caveats
One paper, and a game in a classroom or laboratory. It shows delayed effects being missed, the gap "then what?" tries to close. It did not test the question as a method.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why ask "then what?" more than once?

The first effect is the one everyone already sees. The effects that cost or help the most often come second or third, later and somewhere else.

What is the unseen cost of a choice?

What stops happening because of it. Bastiat's shopkeeper pays the glazier six francs, and the shoes he would have bought never appear.

When should the chain stop?

At about four or five links, or wherever you can no longer say why one effect follows from the last. Past that point, guessing outruns knowing.

Sources
  1. Bastiat F. That which is seen, and that which is not seen. In: Essays on Political Economy. G. P. Putnam's Sons; 1874. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/15962 . French original, Ce qu'on voit et ce qu'on ne voit pas, Guillaumin, July 1850, per https://oll.libertyfund.org/page/wswns
  2. Merton RK. The unanticipated consequences of purposive social action. American Sociological Review. 1936;1(6):894-904. https://doi.org/10.2307/2084615
  3. Lucas DS, Fuller CS. Bounties, grants, and market-making entrepreneurship. The Independent Review. 2018;22(4):507-528. https://www.independent.org/pdf/tir/tir_22_4_02_lucas.pdf
  4. Vann MG. Of rats, rice, and race: The Great Hanoi Rat Massacre, an episode in French colonial history. French Colonial History. 2003;4:191-203. https://doi.org/10.1353/fch.2003.0027
  5. Sterman JD. Modeling managerial behavior: Misperceptions of feedback in a dynamic decision making experiment. Management Science. 1989;35(3):321-339. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.35.3.321

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII