Surgical checklists
Shown in before-and-after studies to be linked with fewer deaths and complications after surgery, though no high-quality trial confirms it.
The numbers and sources
- Effect
- In eight hospitals in eight countries, deaths fell from 1.5% to 0.8% and inpatient complications from 11.0% to 7.0% after the 19-item checklist came in [3]. A meta-analysis of seven studies found risk ratios of 0.59 for any complication, 0.77 for death and 0.57 for surgical-site infection. Larger drops went with closer adherence to the care the checklist names [5].
- Population
- 3,733 patients before and 3,955 after in the eight-hospital study [3]. Seven of 723 screened studies in the meta-analysis [5].
- Caveats
- A before-and-after design cannot separate the checklist from other changes made at the same time. The meta-analysis found marked differences in methods between studies, and called its evidence suggestive, not definitive [5].