07 / 09Study

Sleep on it

The night before an exam often comes down to a trade. Two more hours with the notes, or two more hours of sleep. The same trade shows up before a presentation, an interview, or the first week of a new job, when there is a lot to learn and the evening is the only free time. Staying up feels like the serious choice. The hours are visible and the sleep is not. Memory research has measured both sides of this trade for about a century. Sleep after learning helps hold what was learned. Sleep lost before learning makes new material harder to take in. This lesson lays out what those studies found, and how to put the last review where it does the most.

In five minutesTonight, an hour or two before bed, quiz yourself on ten things you studied today. Sleep your usual night. Tomorrow, before opening anything, write down what you remember.

Method · Sleep and memory  /  Research psychology · Science

↺From last time · Explain it simply

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why do the stumbles matter more than the smooth parts?

A smooth explanation can hide gaps. Each stumble, skipped step or unexplained term marks where understanding runs out, so it shows exactly where to go back to the source.

Why explain to someone new to the subject?

Jargon can stand in for understanding. A newcomer needs every term defined and every step said, and the steps that can't be said are the gaps.

What happened when people in studies tried to explain how everyday devices work?

They rated their own understanding lower afterward. Before trying, they believed they understood things like zippers and locks better than they did.

01Where it comes from

The observation is old. In 1620 Francis Bacon listed "what we think of before going to sleep" among the things that stay longest in memory (see Voices). Laboratory work on it goes back at least to John Jenkins and Karl Dallenbach, who compared forgetting during sleep and waking in 1924 [1]. A 2021 meta-analysis pooled studies published from 1967 to 2019 [2]. Neuroscience has since described what happens during the night. In deep slow-wave sleep the brain replays new memories and redistributes them from the hippocampus to longer-term sites in the cortex, and REM sleep may help strengthen them [3]. A 2007 brain-imaging study looked at the other side, sleep lost before learning, and found a night without sleep weakened the brain's ability to form new memories the next day [4]. Sleep needs and sleep problems vary from person to person.

Also called Sleep consolidation, studying before bed, the all-nighter.

Before going to sleep

Other instances will give us this fourth species; that things which are chiefly imprinted when the mind is clear and not occupied with anything else either before or after, as what is learnt in childhood, or what we think of before going to sleep, also things that happen for the first time, dwell longest in the memory.

Francis Bacon, Novum Organum, Book II Aphorism XXVI · tr. James Spedding

Bacon is sorting aids to memory into kinds. This kind he later calls "impression made on the mind disengaged": learning when nothing crowds in before or after. Sleep is one of his examples, next to childhood and first experiences. His reason is that nothing comes after to crowd the memory out. Modern sleep research gives a different account, built on what the brain does during the night. The observation he started from is the same.

Read it in full

02The method

Sleep and memory

  1. Put the review you most want to keep in the evening, a few hours before your usual bedtime, and test yourself on it.
  2. Sleep your usual full night after it.
  3. The next morning, before opening your notes, recall what you studied. Then check.
  4. Before a test, plan the calendar so the night before is a normal night's sleep.
  5. If a big learning day is coming, such as a first day at a job or a long lecture, protect the night before it too.
  6. Plan new material for days that follow a normal night. Use a day after a short night for review.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on One week's review page, kept by a nursing student with a pharmacology quiz the following Monday

The week of

  • November 9. Pharmacology quiz Monday, November 16, at 10 a.m.

What I learned

  • Mon 8 p.m.: 15 cards on the chapter 4 drug classes, until each was right once. Bed at 11.
  • Tue 7 a.m., before notes: 13 of 15. Missed the two dosing-interval cards.
  • Thu 8 a.m.: 15 cards on chapter 5, until each was right once.
  • Thu 8 p.m., same day, no notes: 10 of 15.
  • One week, one comparison. The night between seemed to help.

What I'll test myself on

  • Friday evening: the 2 misses from chapter 4 and the 5 from chapter 5.
  • Sunday evening: all 30 cards. Monday morning: all 30 again, before notes.

What slipped, and what I'll change

  • Tuesday: up until 1:30 a.m. finishing a lab report. Moved Wednesday's new chapter to Thursday and only reviewed on Wednesday.
  • Next lab report: start it on the weekend so it doesn't take a weeknight.

Next week

  • Sunday: last review in the evening, no new material, bed at 11.
  • Monday 7 a.m.: recall before notes, check only the misses. Quiz at 10.

04Try it · 10 minutes

For a class

Pick 15 questions from one course. In the evening, go through them until you can answer each once. Sleep. The next morning, before looking, answer all 15 and count. Another week, learn 15 different questions in the morning and test yourself that evening, twelve hours later. Compare the two counts. Ten minutes each time.

For work and life

Before a presentation or an interview, rehearse it once in full the evening before. Sleep. In the morning, before looking at your notes, run through it from memory and write down anything that did not come back. Check only those parts. Ten minutes.

The blank page for this is in the Study workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Trading the night for one more pass. In lab studies, a night without sleep after learning reduced memory for what was studied. Weigh that against what one more pass adds.
  • New material after a sleepless night. In lab studies, material learned after a night without sleep was harder to remember. Keep the day after a short night for review.
  • Expecting sleep to add what was never studied. Sleep helps hold what was learned that day. It works on material already studied, ideally tested.
  • Skipping the morning check. The morning recall shows what held overnight. Without it, the next day starts with rereading.

06Research

What research has measured

Sleep after learning

Shown that people recall more after a period of sleep than after the same time awake, a moderate effect that shrinks but holds after correcting for bias.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across 823 effect sizes, the sleep benefit for memory of events and word lists was g = 0.44, and g = 0.28 after correcting for selective reporting. It was larger for nighttime sleep than for daytime naps, and larger when material had been studied more than once [2]. A second meta-analysis found that a night of sleep loss after learning reduced memory by g = 0.277 [5].
Population
271 independent samples from 177 articles [2]. Studies from 1970 to 2020 of at least one full night without sleep [5].
Caveats
Most studies are small laboratory experiments. The second meta-analysis found signs of publication bias and very low statistical power in most studies [5].

Sleep lost before learning

Shown that a night without sleep before learning makes new material harder to remember, with a medium-to-large average effect in laboratory studies.

The numbers and sources
Effect
One full night without sleep before learning reduced later memory by g = 0.621 [5]. In a brain-imaging study, sleep-deprived people showed less hippocampal activity while learning and remembered less afterward [4]. In a survey at one college, 60% of students reported at least one all-nighter, and all-nighters were linked with lower grade point averages [6].
Population
Studies from 1970 to 2020 [5]. Healthy young adults. The abstract does not give the number [4]. 120 students with a mean age of 20.1 [6].
Caveats
The meta-analysis found publication bias and low power [5]. The survey is correlational, so all-nighters may go with other habits that affect grades [6]. A full night of lost sleep in a lab is more extreme than a short night.

A nap compared with cramming

One study found that an hour's nap between study sessions protected memory a week later better than spending that hour cramming.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Young adults learned detailed facts in sessions around one hour spent napping, taking a break, or cramming the same facts. Thirty minutes later, cramming and napping both beat the break. A week later napping kept its advantage and cramming did not [7].
Population
84 young adults: 27 nap, 27 break, 30 cramming [7].
Caveats
One small study. The meta-analysis above found smaller benefits for daytime naps than for nighttime sleep [2].

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why put the most important review in the evening?

In studies, people recalled more after a period of sleep than after the same hours awake. An evening review, with a self-test, puts a night's sleep right after the material.

Why keep new material away from the day after a short night?

In lab studies, a night without sleep before learning made new material harder to remember. Reviewing what is already learned is the better use of that day.

What does the morning check show?

What held overnight. Recalling before opening the notes tests it, and the misses become that day's short list.

Sources
  1. Jenkins JG, Dallenbach KM. Obliviscence during sleep and waking. The American Journal of Psychology. 1924;35(4):605. https://doi.org/10.2307/1414040
  2. Berres S, Erdfelder E. The sleep benefit in episodic memory: An integrative review and a meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin. 2021;147(12):1309-1353. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000350
  3. Diekelmann S, Born J. The memory function of sleep. Nature Reviews Neuroscience. 2010;11(2):114-126. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn2762
  4. Yoo SS, Hu PT, Gujar N, Jolesz FA, Walker MP. A deficit in the ability to form new human memories without sleep. Nature Neuroscience. 2007;10(3):385-392. https://doi.org/10.1038/nn1851
  5. Newbury CR, Crowley R, Rastle K, Tamminen J. Sleep deprivation and memory: Meta-analytic reviews of studies on sleep deprivation before and after learning. Psychological Bulletin. 2021;147(11):1215-1240. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000348
  6. Thacher PV. University students and the "all nighter": Correlates and patterns of students' engagement in a single night of total sleep deprivation. Behavioral Sleep Medicine. 2008;6(1):16-31. https://doi.org/10.1080/15402000701796114
  7. Cousins JN, Wong KF, Raghunath BL, Look C, Chee MWL. The long-term memory benefits of a daytime nap compared with cramming. Sleep. 2019;42(1):zsy207. https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/zsy207

In MVIII: Today. The day's workout, food and tasks on one list. Get MVIII