08 / 09Study

Plan back from the date

An exam five weeks away feels far off. There is time for everything, so nothing in particular happens this week. Then it is ten days away, and the plan becomes all of it at once. At work the shape is the same for a report due at the end of the quarter, a certification, a launch, or a move. Planning forward from today asks what to do first. Planning back from the date asks what has to be true the day before, and the day before that. The second question tends to turn up steps the first one misses, along with the fact that the calendar is shorter than it looked. This lesson builds a study calendar from the end.

In five minutesWrite your next deadline at the bottom of a page. Above it, write the step that must be done the day before. Keep going up, one step at a time, until you reach today.

Method · Backward planning  /  Research psychology · Business

↺From last time · Sleep on it

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why put the most important review in the evening?

In studies, people recalled more after a period of sleep than after the same hours awake. An evening review, with a self-test, puts a night's sleep right after the material.

Why keep new material away from the day after a short night?

In lab studies, a night without sleep before learning made new material harder to remember. Reviewing what is already learned is the better use of that day.

What does the morning check show?

What held overnight. Recalling before opening the notes tests it, and the misses become that day's short list.

01Where it comes from

Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky named the planning fallacy in 1979: people trust their own plan even when they know most similar projects ran late [1]. In 1994 Roger Buehler, Dale Griffin and Michael Ross measured it in honors students finishing their theses, and found people predicted their own tasks far more optimistically than other people's [1]. Practitioners commonly advise starting from the goal and working back [2]. Psychologists have tested it directly only recently. Wiese, Buehler and Griffin compared backward and forward planning on time estimates in 2016 [2]. Jooyoung Park, Fang-Chi Lu and William Hedgcock compared them on motivation and performance in 2017 [3]. Giving each step a time and a place comes from a separate line of work, on implementation intentions, led by Peter Gollwitzer [4].

Also called Reverse planning, backward scheduling, study calendar, planning fallacy.

02The method

Backward planning

  1. Write the exam or deadline date at the bottom of a page or calendar.
  2. Work backward. Name the last step before the date, such as a full practice test two days before. Then the step before that, and so on, back to today.
  3. Give each step a date, a time and a place: "Tuesday, 7 p.m., kitchen table, chapter 3 questions."
  4. Look at how long a similar job took last time. Stretch your estimates to match that, not your hopes.
  5. Leave two or three empty days before the date as a buffer.
  6. Check the plan once a week. Move the steps that slipped, and keep the date fixed.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on A study calendar for a biology midterm on chapters 5 to 8, built on Monday, November 16, from the exam date back

The date it is due, and what it is

  • Thursday, December 10, 9 a.m. Biology 101 midterm, chapters 5 to 8.

Week 1

  • Thu 10: Midterm, 9 a.m. A normal night's sleep before it.
  • Wed 9: 7 p.m., kitchen table. The practice test's misses. Bed by 11.
  • Tue 8: 7 p.m., library, second floor. Full practice test, timed, 75 minutes.
  • Mon 7: 7 p.m., kitchen table. All cards, chapters 5 to 8.

Week 2

  • Sat 5 and Sun 6: empty. Buffer.
  • Thu 3: 7 p.m., library. Chapter 8 cards.
  • Tue 1: 7 p.m., library. Chapter 7 cards.
  • Mon 30: 7 p.m., kitchen table. Chapters 5 and 6 cards.

Week 3

  • Wed 25 to Sun 29: away for Thanksgiving. Nothing planned.
  • Tue 24: 7 p.m., library. Chapter 8 first pass. Write its cards.
  • Mon 23: 7 p.m., kitchen table. Chapter 7 first pass. Write its cards.

Week 4

  • Sun 22: 4 p.m., kitchen table. Chapter 6 cards, first review.
  • Sat 21: 10 a.m., library. Chapter 6 first pass. Write its cards.
  • Thu 19: 7 p.m., kitchen table. Chapter 5 cards, first review.
  • Tue 17: 7 p.m., kitchen table. Chapter 5 first pass. Write its cards.
  • Mon 16: this plan.

Against last time

  • Last midterm: 7 sessions, all in the final 8 days. One chapter never got a second look.
  • This plan: 12 sessions over 24 days, two buffer days, and every chapter reviewed at least twice.

04Try it · 25 minutes

For a class

Take your next exam date. Starting from it, count back: a full practice test two days before, a session on its misses the day after, spaced reviews of each chapter's questions, and one first pass per chapter. Put every session on a dated calendar with a time and place. Then compare the total with how long your last exam's preparation really took. About 25 minutes.

For work and life

Pick a deadline: a report, a certification, a launch, a move. Write the date, then the step that must be done the day before, then the one before that, back to today. Give each a date. Then look up how long the last similar project took from start to finish, and compare it with your plan's total. Adjust the steps or the scope.

The blank page for this is in the Study workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Trusting the best-case guess. In one study, students' best estimate for finishing a thesis was 34 days. They took 56, and under a third finished by their own estimate. Check against past jobs.
  • Steps without a time or place. "Study chapter 3" leaves the when open every day. A step with a day, an hour and a place has already been decided.
  • No buffer. A plan that uses every day breaks at the first sick day. Leave empty days before the date.
  • Planning only once. The first plan is a guess. A weekly check moves slipped steps before they pile up near the date.
  • Dropping the plan after one miss. One missed session moves one step. Reschedule it and keep the rest.

06Research

What research has measured

The planning fallacy

Shown that people predict their own tasks will finish sooner than they do, and that recalling how long similar past tasks took can correct it.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Honors students predicted they would finish their theses in 33.9 days on average. They took 55.5 days. Only 29.7% finished by their own best estimate, and even their worst-case estimates averaged 48.6 days. In a later study the optimistic bias disappeared when people were asked to connect relevant past experiences to their prediction. Observers predicting others' tasks erred the other way [1].
Population
37 psychology honors students in the first of five studies [1].
Caveats
One paper, mostly with university students. The fix that removed the bias was tested in one study [1].

Planning from the end

Early studies suggest planning backward from the deadline leads to longer, more realistic time estimates and, in some studies, better follow-through.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across four experiments, people who planned backward predicted longer completion times than those who planned forward or in no set order, and in one experiment their predictions were less biased [2]. Backward planning also led to greater motivation, higher expectations of reaching the goal, less time pressure, and better goal-related performance than forward planning, especially for complex goals [3].
Population
Four experiments [2]. The abstract of [3] does not give the number of studies or participants.
Caveats
A small literature from two research groups. The 2017 paper was followed by a published correction in 2018 [5].

Saying when and where in advance

Shown that plans naming when, where and how to act help people act on goals they already hold.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across 94 independent tests, if-then plans spelling out when, where and how to act had a medium-to-large effect on reaching goals, d = .65 [4].
Population
94 independent tests. The abstract does not give a participant count [4].
Caveats
The estimate comes from the authors of the theory and pools many kinds of goals [4]. It appeared in a review series, not a journal.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why plan back from the date instead of forward from today?

Forward planning asks what to do first, and the calendar runs out. Working back asks what must be done before each step. That turns up missing steps, and in studies backward plans allowed more time.

Why compare the plan with how long the last similar job took?

People predict their own tasks will finish sooner than they do. In one study, connecting the prediction to how long similar past tasks really took removed that optimism.

Why give each step a date, a time and a place?

"Study chapter 3" leaves the decision open every day. A step with a when and a where is already decided, and plans like that help people act on goals they already hold.

Sources
  1. Buehler R, Griffin D, Ross M. Exploring the "planning fallacy": Why people underestimate their task completion times. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1994;67(3):366-381. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.67.3.366
  2. Wiese J, Buehler R, Griffin D. Backward planning: Effects of planning direction on predictions of task completion time. Judgment and Decision Making. 2016;11(2):147-167. https://doi.org/10.1017/s1930297500007269
  3. Park J, Lu FC, Hedgcock WM. Relative effects of forward and backward planning on goal pursuit. Psychological Science. 2017;28(11):1620-1630. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797617715510
  4. Gollwitzer PM, Sheeran P. Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. 2006;38:69-119. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(06)38002-1
  5. Corrigendum: Relative effects of forward and backward planning on goal pursuit. Psychological Science. 2018;29(2):312-313. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797617752922

In MVIII: Today. The day's workout, food and tasks on one list. Get MVIII