06 / 09Study

Explain it simply

Someone at dinner asks how a vaccine works, or why interest rates move, or what a new project at work is actually for. The first sentence comes easily. The second one trails off. In a class the same moment arrives when the teacher calls on someone, or a study partner asks a simple "why?" At work it comes when a new hire asks how a process runs, start to finish. In studies, people rate their understanding of everyday things higher before they try to explain them than after. The gap only shows up when the explanation is attempted out loud or on paper. This lesson uses that moment on purpose. The stumbles are the useful part. Each one marks a place to go back to.

In five minutesPick one idea from today. Explain it in five plain sentences, on paper, to someone who has never heard of it. Circle the sentence where you got stuck.

Method · Explain it simply  /  Skill · Explain  /  Teaching · Science

↺From last time · Mix it up

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why does mixed practice help on a mixed test?

In a block, the method is known before the problem is read. A mixed set makes you decide which method each problem needs, and that decision is the first job on every exam question.

Why expect lower scores while practicing mixed?

Choosing the method each time is harder than repeating one. In one math study, mixed practice scored lower during practice and far higher on a test a week later.

When is mixing the wrong choice?

For word lists, where blocked study did better, and before any kind has been learned. Mixing pays off most for similar things that are easy to confuse.

01Where it comes from

The habit is usually credited to Richard Feynman, the Caltech physicist who shared the 1965 Nobel Prize in Physics and was known for his teaching. His colleague David Goodstein wrote in 1989 that putting a subject at the level of a first-year lecture was Feynman's test of whether it was really understood (see Voices) [1]. "The Feynman technique" is a later name. Feynman did not name it or write it up as a technique. The earliest use of the name we found is a 2011 blog post by the learning writer Scott Young, 23 years after Feynman's death [2]. Research psychology studies the parts under other names. Michelene Chi and colleagues showed in 1994 that prompting students to explain each line of a text to themselves improved understanding [3]. Other work looks at learning by preparing to teach [4] and at how much people overrate their own understanding [5].

Also called The Feynman technique, self-explanation, learning by teaching, the illusion of explanatory depth.

The freshman test

You know, I couldn't do it. I couldn't reduce it to the freshman level. That means we really don't understand it.

Richard Feynman, as recalled by David Goodstein, Richard P. Feynman, Teacher (Physics Today) Physics Today, volume 42, number 2, February 1989, page 75

Goodstein had asked Feynman to explain why particles of spin one-half obey Fermi-Dirac statistics. Feynman said he would prepare a freshman lecture on it, and came back a few days later with this. Goodstein calls reducing physics for young students "the standard by which he measured whether something was really understood." In the story the failure points at the field, not at Feynman. The test is the same one this lesson uses.

Read it in full

Not fooling yourself

The first principle is that you must not fool yourself

Richard Feynman, Cargo Cult Science, Caltech commencement address Engineering and Science, volume 37, number 7, June 1974

Feynman was talking to graduating students about scientific integrity, and about results that look like science without being it. He adds that you are "the easiest person to fool." The talk is about experiments, not studying. The same warning fits the feeling of understanding something. That feeling is easy to have and hard to check, and an explanation written out is one way to check it.

Read it in full

02The method

Explain it simply

  1. Pick one idea, process or argument. Write its name at the top of a blank page.
  2. Explain it in plain words to an imagined smart person who has never studied it. Define any term you can't avoid.
  3. Give an example. Say why each step follows from the one before it.
  4. Circle every place where you stumble, skip a step, or reach for a term you can't unpack.
  5. Go back to the source for the circled places only. Then explain those parts again.
  6. Give the explanation to a real person, out loud, and answer their questions.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on Chapter 1 of the Enchiridion, about 400 words, explained to a friend who has never read any Stoic philosophy

What I'm explaining

  • Epictetus, Enchiridion chapter 1: what is in our power and what is not.

Explained in plain words, to someone new to it

  • Epictetus sorts everything into two piles. One pile is yours: what you think of things, what you go after, what you want and what you avoid. The other pile isn't: your body, your things, what people think of you, your position. The first pile is (circled: free?). The second is not. If you treat the second pile as yours, you end up frustrated and blaming people (circled: why?). So when something hits hard, he says to call it an (circled: appearance) and ask which pile it is in. If it's the second pile, (circled: it does not concern you).

Where I got stuck or reached for jargon

  • "Free": I used it without saying free from what.
  • Why claiming the second pile leads to blame. I said it and didn't explain it.
  • "Appearance": I used his word and couldn't say what it means.
  • "Does not concern you": does he mean stop caring about your own body?

What I looked up

  • Free: "not subject to restraint or hindrance." No one can block an opinion or a desire. Others can block my body or my property.
  • Blame: the second pile is "in the power of others." Treat it as mine and others keep blocking me, so I blame them.
  • Appearance: how a thing first strikes me. He says to tell a harsh one, "You are an appearance."
  • He says "does not concern you" of the harsh appearance, once tested. The chapter says nothing about neglecting the body.

Explained again, shorter

  • Some things answer to you: your judgments, your wants, what you avoid. No one can block those. Others don't: your body, your things, your reputation, your position. Other people can block those. Claim them as yours and you keep getting blocked, and you blame someone. So when something hits hard, first ask which kind it is. If it isn't yours to control, be ready to say it isn't your concern.
The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 20 minutes

For a class

After a lecture on a process or argument, put your notes away and write a one-page explanation for a first-year student. Fifteen minutes. Circle the stumbles, check them in the textbook, and rewrite those lines. To practice on a hosted text, read William James's The Laws of Habit, then explain in plain words why James thinks habits form and why he thinks teachers should care.

Open it in the reader: Habit, The Laws of Habit

For work and life

Before a meeting where you will present a decision or a new process, explain it in writing to an imagined new hire, in under 200 words and with one example. Circle the parts you glossed over. Fill those in from the source, then say the explanation out loud to a colleague and note the first question they ask.

The blank page for this is in the Study workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Simplifying past the truth. Plain words are the aim. Dropping the hard step is a different thing. Keep every step, and make each one clear.
  • Explaining from the notes. Reading notes aloud tests reading. Put them away before you start.
  • Saying what without why. A list of facts is a summary. The method asks why each step follows from the last.
  • Moving past the stumbles. The circled gaps are the whole output. Go back to the source for each one.
  • Taking a smooth answer as proof. An explanation can feel clear until a hard question arrives. Ask yourself the question a doubter would.

06Research

What research has measured

Explaining to yourself while studying

Shown that prompting learners to explain material to themselves while studying improves learning, by a medium amount on average.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across 69 effect sizes, self-explanation prompts improved learning by g = .55. Self-explanation beat being given an instructor's explanation by g = .35, and beat no added explanation by g = .67 [6]. Eighth graders prompted to explain each line of a text on the circulatory system gained more from pretest to posttest than classmates who read it twice [3].
Population
5,917 participants in 64 research reports [6]. 14 prompted and 10 unprompted eighth graders [3].
Caveats
Self-explaining often took more study time, and time was rarely reported. Multiple-choice prompts and prompts about one's own planning showed no clear effect [6]. A 2013 review rated self-explanation moderate utility because it had not been tested enough in real classrooms [7].

Preparing to teach, and teaching

Shown that studying in order to teach, and then teaching, improves learning compared with studying alone.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Preparing to teach improved learning by g = 0.35, and teaching after preparing by g = 0.56, compared with studying with no plan to teach. Gains held after a delay and on deeper questions. Interactive teaching gave larger gains than non-interactive teaching, and so did merely expecting to teach interactively [4].
Population
28 studies [4]. The abstract does not give a participant count.
Caveats
One meta-analysis. The size of the effect depended on what kind of teaching learners expected and did [4].

Overrating our own understanding

Early studies suggest people rate their understanding of how everyday things work lower after trying to explain them step by step.

The numbers and sources
Effect
People rated how well they understood devices such as a zipper, a flush toilet and a cylinder lock on a 1 to 7 scale. Among undergraduates, the average fell from 3.89 to 3.10 after writing an explanation, and to 2.49 after answering a diagnostic question. The illusion was strongest for how things work, and weaker for facts, procedures and stories [5].
Population
16 graduate students and 33 undergraduates at one university in the first two of twelve studies [5].
Caveats
Small samples from one university, measured with self-ratings [5].

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why do the stumbles matter more than the smooth parts?

A smooth explanation can hide gaps. Each stumble, skipped step or unexplained term marks where understanding runs out, so it shows exactly where to go back to the source.

Why explain to someone new to the subject?

Jargon can stand in for understanding. A newcomer needs every term defined and every step said, and the steps that can't be said are the gaps.

What happened when people in studies tried to explain how everyday devices work?

They rated their own understanding lower afterward. Before trying, they believed they understood things like zippers and locks better than they did.

Sources
  1. Goodstein DL. Richard P. Feynman, teacher. Physics Today. 1989;42(2):70-75. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.881195
  2. Young SH. Learn faster with the Feynman Technique. Scott H. Young, September 1, 2011. https://www.scotthyoung.com/blog/2011/09/01/learn-faster/
  3. Chi MTH, De Leeuw N, Chiu MH, LaVancher C. Eliciting self-explanations improves understanding. Cognitive Science. 1994;18(3):439-477. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15516709cog1803_3
  4. Kobayashi K. Learning by preparing-to-teach and teaching: A meta-analysis. Japanese Psychological Research. 2019;61(3):192-203. https://doi.org/10.1111/jpr.12221
  5. Rozenblit L, Keil F. The misunderstood limits of folk science: An illusion of explanatory depth. Cognitive Science. 2002;26(5):521-562. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15516709cog2605_1
  6. Bisra K, Liu Q, Nesbit JC, Salimi F, Winne PH. Inducing self-explanation: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review. 2018;30(3):703-725. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-018-9434-x
  7. Dunlosky J, Rawson KA, Marsh EJ, Nathan MJ, Willingham DT. Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques: Promising directions from cognitive and educational psychology. Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 2013;14(1):4-58. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100612453266

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII