07 / 10Notes

The slip box

Months after reading a good book, one idea from it comes back during a meeting or an essay, and the page it came from is gone. Most notes are filed by source: one notebook per class, one folder per book. Ideas travel between sources. A point from a history lecture answers a question in economics. A line from a podcast settles an argument at work. A slip box files notes by idea. Each card holds one thought, written as full sentences in your own words. Each card has an address, and each one names the cards it connects to. Over the years the links become the useful part. A new paper, talk or proposal starts by following a trail already laid.

In five minutesPick one idea from today. Write it on a card in two or three full sentences, without looking at the source. Number it 1. Tomorrow, write card 2 and note how it connects to 1.

Method · Zettelkasten  /  Skill · Connect  /  Writing

↺From last time · Notes for problems

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why write a reason beside every step?

Steps alone fit only the problem they came from. The reason, the rule each step applies, is what carries over to the next problem that looks different.

Why cover the next step of a worked example before reading it?

Predicting the step makes you explain the example to yourself. Students who learn most from examples tend to anticipate the next step and name the principle behind it.

What does an error log add to simply redoing the homework?

It names the exact step that went wrong and the rule missed, then sets a retry from a blank page days later. The mistake becomes feedback and a delayed test.

01Where it comes from

Niklas Luhmann (1927 to 1998) was a German sociologist who taught at Bielefeld University from 1968 to 1993 [1]. From the early 1950s until 1996 he kept a card index, a Zettelkasten, of about 90,000 slips [2]. The first collection, from about 1952 to 1962, holds about 24,000 slips. The second, from about 1963 to 1996, holds about 66,000. Every slip has a fixed number, so a new slip can branch off any old one. About 50,000 cross-references link slips across the collection, and keyword indexes of about 1,250 and 3,200 entries give the ways in [1]. Bielefeld's Niklas Luhmann-Archiv has digitized the collection. Luhmann published close to 600 works, over 40 of them books [2]. Sönke Ahrens turned the practice into a method for students and writers in How to Take Smart Notes (2017) [3]. Nothing has tested the method itself in a controlled study.

Also called Slip box, slip-box notes, Luhmann's card index, smart notes.

02The method

Zettelkasten

  1. Keep three kinds of notes apart: quick jottings on anything, notes on what you read with the source, and the cards in the box.
  2. Write each card about one idea, in full sentences and your own words, so it makes sense without the source beside it.
  3. Give each card a fixed address. Number it after the card it continues, as 12, 12a, 12a1, or use the date. Never renumber.
  4. Before filing a card, find one to three cards it relates to. Write their addresses on the new card, and the new address on them.
  5. Add an index entry: a keyword with the address of one or two cards where a trail begins.
  6. Once a jotting's idea is on a card, throw the jotting away. Keep the source notes in a separate file.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on Three cards from chapter 1 of the Enchiridion, filed in a box that already holds notes from work

Note 14

  • One idea, in my own words: Epictetus sorts everything into what is our own act and what is not. Opinion, desire and aversion are ours. Body, property, reputation and office are not. Only the first kind is fully free.
  • Links to notes: 14a (what mixing them up costs), 14b (the test), 6 (project reviews)
  • Source: Enchiridion 1, Long. Source notes in the file "Epictetus".

Note 14a

  • One idea, in my own words: Distress comes from treating what belongs to others as our own. The costs he lists: being hindered, lamenting, being disturbed, blaming gods and people.
  • Links to notes: 14 (continues it)
  • Source: Enchiridion 1, Long

Note 14b

  • One idea, in my own words: The practice is a question asked the moment something harsh appears: is this in my power? If not, it does not concern me. A habit to run, not a belief to hold.
  • Links to notes: 14 (applies it), 6 (same test at work)
  • Source: Enchiridion 1, Long

Note 6

  • One idea, in my own words: In our launch review, the useful hour sorted causes into ones the team could change and ones it could not. Time on the second kind produced complaints and no changes.
  • Links to notes: 14b (same sort, about 1,900 years older), added today
  • Source: my notes, spring launch review

Index

  • Control, what is up to me: 14
  • Reviews and post-mortems: 6
The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 30 minutes

For a class

Take three ideas from this week's lectures or reading, from different classes if you can. Write each on its own card in two to four sentences, without looking at the source. Number them 1, 2 and 3. On each card, write in one line which other card it connects to and how. Start an index card with three keywords. About 25 minutes.

For work and life

For one week, write a card each day for one idea from work: a lesson from a project, a line from a book, something a colleague explained. One idea per card, in sentences. Before filing each new card, link it to at least one older card. At the end of the week, follow the links and write one paragraph the cards together suggest.

The blank page for this is in the Notes workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Filling the box with quotes. A card of quotations holds someone else's thinking. Keep quotes with your source notes, and put your own sentences about the idea on the card.
  • Folders instead of links. Filing cards by subject brings back the notebook. The box exists for the connections between subjects.
  • Cards that hold three ideas. A long card can only be linked as a whole. Split it.
  • Building the system before the notes. Hours spent choosing apps and tags leave the box empty. Paper cards or one folder of plain text files is enough.
  • No index. Without entry points, old cards sit unfound. Add a keyword whenever a card starts a new trail.

06Research

What research has measured

Generating beats reading

Shown that information people produce themselves is remembered better than the same information read. This is a related mechanism, not a test of the slip box.

The numbers and sources
Effect
In the first five experiments, words participants generated were remembered better than the same words read, on recognition, free recall and cued recall [4]. A meta-analysis of 445 effect sizes from 86 studies put the advantage at .40 of a standard deviation [5]. A later meta-analysis of 126 articles, 310 experiments and 1,653 estimates found the size of the effect depends on how constrained the generating is [6].
Population
Mostly laboratory participants generating words or short items, such as producing a synonym [4][5][6].
Caveats
These studies tested single words and short items over short delays. Writing a card in your own words involves generating, but no study here tested a card index or links between notes.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why one idea per card?

A card can only be linked as a whole. One idea per card lets each idea join any trail without dragging two others along.

Why give each card a fixed address that never changes?

Links point at addresses. Renumbering would break every link to the card. A fixed address also lets a new card branch off any old one, as 12a after 12.

Why write the card in your own words instead of copying the source?

What you produce yourself is remembered better than what you read. A card in full sentences also still makes sense years later, without the source beside it.

Sources
  1. Schmidt J, Gödel M, Zimmer S. Die Digitalisierung des Zettelkastens Niklas Luhmanns. Lecture, Universität Bielefeld, April 19, 2018. https://uni-bielefeld.de/einrichtungen/bits/ueber-uns/knowledge-transfer/2018/2018-04-19_Vortrag_Das_Digitalisierungsprojekt_Luhmann-Zettelkasten.pdf
  2. Universität Bielefeld. Niklas Luhmann-Archiv. https://www.uni-bielefeld.de/fakultaeten/soziologie/forschung/luhmann-archiv/
  3. Ahrens S. How to Take Smart Notes: One Simple Technique to Boost Writing, Learning and Thinking. Self-published; 2017. first edition
  4. Slamecka NJ, Graf P. The generation effect: Delineation of a phenomenon. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory. 1978;4(6):592-604. https://doi.org/10.1037/0278-7393.4.6.592
  5. Bertsch S, Pesta BJ, Wiscott R, McDaniel MA. The generation effect: A meta-analytic review. Memory & Cognition. 2007;35(2):201-210. https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03193441
  6. McCurdy MP, Viechtbauer W, Sklenar AM, Frankenstein AN, Leshikar ED. Theories of the generation effect and the impact of generation constraint: A meta-analytic review. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review. 2020;27(6):1139-1165. https://doi.org/10.3758/s13423-020-01762-3

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII