08 / 10Notes

The commonplace book

Some lines stick. A sentence in a novel, a figure in a report, a thing a grandparent used to say. Most of them end up lost in screenshots, or in the margins of books long since given away. For centuries, readers kept them in one notebook. They copied the passage, wrote down where it came from, and filed it under a heading: Courage, Money, Work, Grief. Years later, writing a letter or a speech, they opened the book at the heading and found what they had gathered from many sources in one place. The commonplace book is the older form of the slip box in the last lesson. Both file notes by subject. Reading done years apart meets on one page.

In five minutesOpen a notebook to a blank page. Copy one line that stopped you this week, with author, title and page. Under it, write two lines of your own. Give it a one-word heading.

Method · Commonplace book  /  Skill · Connect  /  Writing · History

↺From last time · The slip box

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why one idea per card?

A card can only be linked as a whole. One idea per card lets each idea join any trail without dragging two others along.

Why give each card a fixed address that never changes?

Links point at addresses. Renumbering would break every link to the card. A fixed address also lets a new card branch off any old one, as 12a after 12.

Why write the card in your own words instead of copying the source?

What you produce yourself is remembered better than what you read. A card in full sentences also still makes sense years later, without the source beside it.

01Where it comes from

The name comes from the commonplaces of ancient rhetoric, the stock headings where an orator went looking for arguments. Renaissance teachers, among them Guarino da Verona, Erasmus and Vives, wrote instructions for keeping such notebooks, and pupils kept them through a lifetime of reading [1]. The habit is older than the name. Seneca, writing to his friend Lucilius in the first century, compared good reading to bees gathering from many flowers and making one honey [2]. John Locke worked out a way to index a commonplace book and published it in French in 1686. An English translation appeared in 1706 [3]. His method became popular in the eighteenth century, when readers used it to organize notes, observations and the words of favorite authors [4]. No study has tested the commonplace book itself.

Also called Commonplacing, Locke's index.

The bees

We should follow, men say, the example of the bees, who flit about and cull the flowers that are suitable for producing honey, and then arrange and assort in their cells all that they have brought in

Seneca, Moral Letters to Lucilius, Letter 84, "On Gathering Ideas" Letter 84, section 3 · tr. Richard Mott Gummere

Seneca opens the letter by saying reading and writing should take turns, "so that the fruits of one’s reading may be reduced to concrete form by the pen." The bees are his picture of how. Gather widely, sort what you gathered, then blend it into something of your own. A few lines later he names the risk. Reading left undigested "will merely enter the memory and not the reasoning power." Copying the passage is the gathering. The lines in your own words are the honey.

Read it in full

Locke's index

Rule the first two facing pages into a grid: twenty letters, each with five rows, one for each vowel. File every entry under a head word, and index the head by its first letter and the vowel after it, so "Epistle" goes in the E-I square with its page number.

Our paraphrase of the passage.

John Locke, A New Method of Making Common-Place-Books The method, pages 4 to 7 of the 1706 English edition

Locke says he had used the method for twenty-five years. It solves a plain problem: finding things in a notebook that grows without a plan. The index takes two pages, whatever the size of the book. A new heading gets the next empty pair of facing pages, and the index records where. Entries go in the order they come, and the index finds them. Luhmann's numbered slips answer the same problem three centuries later.

Read it in full

02The method

Commonplace book

  1. Use one notebook. Number the pages. Leave the first two facing pages blank for an index.
  2. When a passage stops you, copy it exactly, with the author, title and page.
  3. Under it, write two or three lines in your own words: what it means, and where you might use it.
  4. File it under a heading of one or two words. Write the heading in the margin so it shows at a glance.
  5. Index the heading. Locke's way: a grid of first letters and vowels, so "Epistle" goes in the E-I square with its page number.
  6. Every few months, read all the pages under one heading together and write a paragraph that joins them.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on Three entries from one week of reading, two from chapter 1 of the Enchiridion and one from the Meditations of Marcus Aurelius, then a paragraph joining one heading

Heading: Control

  • Passage: Of things some are in our power, and others are not.
  • Source: Epictetus, Enchiridion, chapter 1, Long's translation.
  • Mine: The whole chapter rests on this one sort. Use it the next time a delayed flight or a bad review eats an evening: which part of this is mine?

Heading: Saying no

  • Passage: you must leave alone some things entirely, and postpone others for the present.
  • Source: Epictetus, Enchiridion, chapter 1, Long's translation.
  • Mine: Big aims cost other things. Worth rereading when the calendar is full and someone asks for one more project.

Heading: Control

  • Passage: Take away thy opinion, and then there is taken away the complaint, "I have been harmed."
  • Source: Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, Book 4, section 7, Long's translation, 1862.
  • Mine: Same move as Epictetus: the harm runs through the opinion. Marcus thanks Rusticus in Book 1 for the discourses of Epictetus, so the echo may be a debt.

Control, read through

  • Two writers, one idea. Epictetus sorts what is mine from what is not. Marcus shows what the sort does: drop the opinion and the complaint goes with it. Neither says the flight was not late. Both say the evening is still mine.
The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 25 minutes

For a class

During one week of reading for a class, copy five passages onto a commonplace page, each with its source. Under each, write two lines in your own words, and give each a heading. At the end of the week, pick the heading with the most entries and write one paragraph that uses at least two of them. About 25 minutes across the week.

For work and life

Start a commonplace page for one question you keep coming back to at work, such as hiring, pricing or handing off a project. For a month, add any passage from a book, article, talk or colleague that bears on it, with the source and two lines of your own. Then write one paragraph answering the question from your entries.

The blank page for this is in the Notes workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Only copying. A page of quotations stores the words and skips the digesting. Add your own two lines under every entry.
  • A heading for every entry. Too many headings split the book into fragments. Reuse headings and keep them broad.
  • No source. A great line with no page number is hard to use or check. Write author, title and page every time.
  • Never reading a heading through. The payoff comes when entries meet. Now and then, read one heading's pages together.

06Research

What research has measured

Explaining it to yourself

Shown that prompting learners to explain material to themselves improves learning across many kinds of tasks. This is a related mechanism, not a test of the commonplace book.

The numbers and sources
Effect
A meta-analysis of 69 effect sizes from 64 research reports found an overall effect of g = 0.55 for self-explanation prompts given while studying or solving problems [5].
Population
Learners at several levels of education, studying text, studying worked problems or solving problems [5].
Caveats
The prompts were written by instructors and asked learners for inferences about causes and relationships. Writing two lines under a quotation is a looser version, and no study here tested it.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why write two lines of your own under each passage?

Copying stores the words. Your own lines digest them: what the passage means and where you would use it. That is the step from gathering to making something of your own.

Why file entries under headings instead of by source?

Headings bring reading done years apart onto the same pages. Opening one heading puts everything gathered on that subject in one place.

What does an index do for a notebook that grows without a plan?

Entries go in the order they come. The index records where each heading lives, so anything can be found without ever sorting the book.

Sources
  1. Blair A. Humanist methods in natural philosophy: The commonplace book. Journal of the History of Ideas. 1992;53(4):541. https://doi.org/10.2307/2709935
  2. Seneca. Ad Lucilium Epistulae Morales, volume 2. Gummere RM, trans. Loeb Classical Library. Heinemann; 1920. https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Moral_letters_to_Lucilius/Letter_84
  3. Locke J. A New Method of Making Common-Place-Books. J. Greenwood; 1706. https://archive.org/details/b30540434
  4. Dacome L. Noting the mind: Commonplace books and the pursuit of the self in eighteenth-century Britain. Journal of the History of Ideas. 2004;65(4):603-625. https://doi.org/10.1353/jhi.2005.0013
  5. Bisra K, Liu Q, Nesbit JC, Salimi F, Winne PH. Inducing self-explanation: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review. 2018;30(3):703-725. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-018-9434-x

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII