04 / 10Notes

Notes while reading

Reading a chapter and remembering it are two different events. A textbook chapter late at night, a business book on a flight, a report before a meeting. The pages go by and every sentence makes sense. A day later, asked what the chapter said, many readers can name the topic and little else. Highlighting feels like progress while it happens. The page turns yellow and the decision about what mattered gets put off. Reading notes move that decision into the reading. A question before you start. A few words in the margin beside the lines that answer it. One sentence at the end of each chapter, in your own words, saying what the chapter claims. Then, some days later, the step that does the most: answering your own questions without the book open.

In five minutesBefore reading tonight, write one question the chapter should answer. After reading, close the book and write one sentence saying what the chapter claims.

Method · Reading notes  /  Skill · Compress  /  Teaching · Philosophy

↺From last time · Brief it, then outline it

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

What makes a fact worth keeping in a brief?

The result depends on it. If a fact could change and the outcome would stay the same, cut it.

Why write the issue as a yes-or-no question?

It forces you to find the exact point in dispute. A yes-or-no question has one answer, the holding, and the reasoning then has to explain it.

Why add to the outline at the end of each unit instead of before the exam?

Merging a few fresh briefs keeps each step small, and the deciding stays yours. An outline started the week before exams turns into copying.

01Where it comes from

Two books from the 1940s set out most of this. The philosopher Mortimer Adler published How to Read a Book in 1940. Among his rules for reading a book closely: state the unity of the whole book in a sentence or a few sentences, set out its major parts and how they are organized, and find the problems the author is trying to solve [1]. That same year his essay "How to Mark a Book" argued for writing in the books you own. The Ohio State University psychologist Francis P. Robinson published Effective Study in 1946. It taught the Survey Q3R method, now called SQ3R: survey, question, read, recite, review [2]. In 2013 a large review of study techniques rated summarizing, highlighting and rereading as low utility, and testing yourself as high [3]. The method below keeps the summary sentence for finding your way back into a book, and leaves the learning to the questions.

Also called Annotating, marginalia, SQ3R.

Reading is not the last step

But when I shall have found the interpreter, the thing that remains is to use the precepts (the lessons). This itself is the only thing to be proud of.

Epictetus, The Enchiridion Chapter 49 · tr. George Long

Chrysippus led the Stoic school in the third century BCE. Epictetus says he wrote obscurely. He imagines a student proud of being able to explain him. The pride is misplaced. Understanding a hard text makes you its interpreter, "a grammarian instead of a philosopher." For Epictetus a further step remains: what was read gets used. A reading note that ends with how the idea applies carries the reading into that step.

Read it in full: The Enchiridion, Chapter 49

02The method

Reading notes

  1. Before reading, skim the headings, the first and last paragraphs, and any summary. Write two or three questions you expect the chapter to answer.
  2. Read one section at a time. Beside the few lines that answer your questions, write a word or two in the margin saying why they matter.
  3. At the end of each section, look away and say or write what it said. Then check.
  4. At the end of the chapter, write one sentence in your own words stating what the chapter claims, not what it covers.
  5. Inside the back cover or on one card, list page numbers with a few words each, as your own index to the book.
  6. Within a week, answer your opening questions from memory before you open the book again.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on Chapter 1 of the Enchiridion, about 400 words

Book and chapter

  • Epictetus, The Enchiridion, chapter 1. George Long's translation.

One sentence for this chapter

  • Epictetus claims that only our own acts, such as opinion, desire and aversion, are in our power, and that treating anything else as ours is what leaves us hindered, disturbed and blaming others.

Questions it raised

  • Before reading: What does "in our power" mean? What is a reader supposed to do differently?
  • Answered: our own acts of judgment, impulse, desire and aversion. Test each harsh appearance and let go of what is not ours.
  • New: Is the body really not in our power? Training changes it. Is the effort ours and the result not?
  • If office and wealth are not in our power, is wanting a promotion a mistake, or only chasing it at any cost?

Words and names to look up

  • hupolaepsis, hormae, echchlisis: Long's Greek, glossed as opinion, movement towards a thing, aversion.
  • "offices (magisterial power)": public posts.
  • "appearance": a technical word here? Find the Greek behind it.

Where I disagree, or want to know more

  • "No man will harm you" sounds too strong. Harm to what, exactly? Maybe only to what is ours, our choices.

Margin notes worth keeping

  • "Of things some are in our power, and others are not." The chapter in one line.
  • "you will be hindered, you will lament, you will be disturbed": the cost.
  • "leave alone some things entirely, and postpone others": saying no.
  • "You are an appearance": the practice.
The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 30 minutes

For a class

Open chapter 1 of the Enchiridion in the reader. Before reading, write two questions its first sentence raises. Read it once, copying at most three lines into your notes with a word on why each matters. Close it and write one sentence saying what Epictetus claims. Two days later, answer your two questions without opening it. About 20 minutes in all.

Open it in the reader: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

For work and life

Take the next nonfiction book or long report you read for work. Before each chapter, write one question you want it to answer. After each chapter, write one sentence that states its claim, not its topic. When you finish, the sentences together make a one-page version of the book. Keep that page with the book or in a file named for it.

The blank page for this is in the Notes workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Highlighting as the note. Color marks a line without saying why. Add a word in the margin, or leave the line unmarked.
  • Topic sentences instead of claims. "This chapter is about control" says little. "Epictetus says only our own judgments, desires and acts are in our power" says what the chapter argues.
  • Notes as long as the book. A notebook that copies the book takes as long to review as the book. One sentence per chapter and a few margin words per page are enough.
  • Stopping at the notes. Notes made while reading feel finished. Answering your questions from memory a few days later is the step the research supports most.

06Research

What research has measured

Ten study techniques, rated

Shown in a large review that summarizing, highlighting and rereading help less, and less reliably, than practice testing and spaced study.

The numbers and sources
Effect
The review rated ten techniques on how well their benefits generalize across learners, materials, conditions and tests. Practice testing and distributed practice were rated high utility. Elaborative interrogation, self-explanation and interleaved practice were rated moderate. Summarization, highlighting, the keyword mnemonic, imagery for text and rereading were rated low [3].
Population
Studies across ages, ability levels, materials and kinds of tests, reviewed by five researchers [3].
Caveats
A narrative review with ratings, not a meta-analysis. The authors note that summarization helps some students on some tasks, under limited conditions, and that more research is needed [3].

Highlighting

Shown to help memory for the text a little and comprehension less, with more benefit for college students than for school students.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Across 36 published articles and 85 effect sizes, highlighting your own text improved memory (0.36) but not comprehension (0.20). Text already highlighted by an instructor improved both (0.44). Learner highlighting helped college students (0.39) more than school students (0.24) [4].
Population
College and K-12 students in experiments published from 1938 to 2019 [4].
Caveats
The comparison was highlighting against plain reading, not against writing notes or testing yourself. The abstract does not say how long after reading the tests came [4].

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why write questions before you start reading?

Questions give the reading a purpose. You notice the lines that answer them, and later the same questions become a test you can take without the book.

Why should the chapter sentence state a claim and not a topic?

A topic can be written without understanding the chapter. A claim says what the author argues, so writing one shows whether you followed it.

Which step does the research support most?

Answering your own questions from memory, days later. A large review rated testing yourself high, and highlighting, summarizing and rereading low.

Sources
  1. Adler MJ. How to Read a Book: The Art of Getting a Liberal Education. Simon and Schuster; 1940. first edition
  2. Robinson FP. Effective Study. Harper and Brothers; 1946. first edition
  3. Dunlosky J, Rawson KA, Marsh EJ, Nathan MJ, Willingham DT. Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques: Promising directions from cognitive and educational psychology. Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 2013;14(1):4-58. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100612453266
  4. Ponce HR, Mayer RE, Méndez EE. Effects of learner-generated highlighting and instructor-provided highlighting on learning from text: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review. 2022;34(2):989-1024. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-021-09654-1

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII