05 / 10Notes

Notes from a video

A recorded lecture plays on a laptop at the kitchen table. A training video for a new job runs in one browser tab while email waits in the next. A forty-minute explainer, a recorded team meeting, an online course with twelve modules. Video can be paused, rewound and sped up. A live speaker allows none of that. Video also runs on without asking anything of the viewer, and minutes can pass with eyes on the screen and attention somewhere else. Notes from a video make the pause button the main tool. Watch a chunk. Stop. Write the point in your own words beside the time it came up, with a question it answers. The times turn the notes into a map back into the video. The questions turn them into a test.

In five minutesNext time you watch a lecture or explainer, pause it every five minutes. Before pressing play again, write one line in your own words with the time beside it.

Method · Notes from video lectures  /  Skill · Compress  /  Research psychology · Teaching

↺From last time · Notes while reading

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why write questions before you start reading?

Questions give the reading a purpose. You notice the lines that answer them, and later the same questions become a test you can take without the book.

Why should the chapter sentence state a claim and not a topic?

A topic can be written without understanding the chapter. A claim says what the author argues, so writing one shows whether you followed it.

Which step does the research support most?

Answering your own questions from memory, days later. A large review rated testing yourself high, and highlighting, summarizing and rereading low.

01Where it comes from

No one person named this method. It gathers findings from research on learning from multimedia. In 2001 the psychologists Richard Mayer and Paul Chandler taught students how lightning forms with a narrated animation. Students who could play it a segment at a time, at their own pace, did better on transfer tests, though not on retention tests [1]. A 2019 meta-analysis named this the segmenting effect [2]. In 2013 Karl Szpunar and colleagues at Harvard split a 21-minute statistics lecture into four parts and quizzed some students after each part [3]. Captions have a literature of their own. A 2015 review by Morton Ann Gernsbacher counted more than 100 studies finding that captions improve comprehension of, attention to and memory for video. They help most for viewers watching in a second language, people learning to read, and viewers who are deaf or hard of hearing [4]. A meta-analysis of on-screen text found the full narration as text helped mainly learners new to a topic, and that key terms alone did better than the full text [5]. Playback speed was tested more recently [6].

Also called Notes from online classes, lecture video notes, timestamp notes, YouTube notes.

02The method

Notes from video lectures

  1. Write the video's title, speaker and length at the top of the page. Under it, write one question you want the video to answer.
  2. Watch about five minutes, or to the end of a topic or slide. Then pause.
  3. With the video paused, say the chunk's main point from memory. Then write it in your own words beside the time the chunk started.
  4. In a third column, write one question that chunk answers. Leave the answer off the page.
  5. Copy word for word only what must stay exact: a formula, a definition, a figure on screen. Use captions or a transcript to check a term, not to copy whole passages.
  6. Speed up to 1.5x or 2x if the speaker is slow, and slow down for dense parts. Spend the saved minutes on the pauses.
  7. Close the video and write a three-line summary. Within a few days, answer the questions cold, and rewatch only the chunks behind the ones you missed.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on A 20-minute recorded lecture from an introductory philosophy course, on chapter 1 of the Enchiridion, watched at 1.5x

Video, speaker and length

  • Intro to Philosophy, week 3: Epictetus on control. Course instructor. 20 minutes, watched at 1.5x.
  • My question going in: what does "in our power" mean?

Time · Note, in my own words · Question to test later

  • 0:00 · Epictetus was born a slave and later freed. He taught and wrote nothing. His student Arrian wrote the teaching down, and the Enchiridion is a short handbook drawn from it. · Q: Why is the book not by Epictetus's own hand?
  • 4:30 · The first line splits all things in two. Ours: opinion, impulse, desire, aversion, our own acts. Not ours: body, property, reputation, office. · Q: What goes on each side of the split?
  • 9:10 · Mixing them up has a price: hindered, lamenting, blaming gods and people. · Q: What does it cost to treat what is not ours as ours?
  • 13:40 · Great aims take more than a small effort. Some things get dropped, some put off. Chasing wealth and office as well risks both. · Q: Why not go after everything at once?
  • 17:20 · The practice: tell a harsh impression "You are an appearance." Then ask whether it is in our power. If not, it does not concern you. (Rewound once. Captions on to catch "appearance".) · Q: What are the two steps when something harsh shows up?

Summary, written with the video closed

  • Epictetus sorts everything into our own acts and everything else. Distress comes from treating the second kind as ours. The habit: stop at each harsh impression, ask which kind it is, and let go of what is not ours.
The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 30 minutes

For a class

Take the next recorded lecture for one course, or a 20-minute lecture from any open online course. Rule a page into three columns: time, note, question. Pause at least every five minutes and fill one row before going on. At the end, close the video and write a three-line summary. Two days later, cover the notes and answer the questions. Rewatch only the chunks you missed. About 30 minutes.

For work and life

Use the method on a training video, a recorded meeting or a long explainer you meant to watch anyway. Pause at each new topic and write the time, the point, and a question a teammate might ask about it. Afterward, send the summary and two time stamps to someone who missed it, so they can jump straight to the parts that matter.

The blank page for this is in the Notes workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Watching straight through. Twenty minutes without a pause leaves notes written from a blur. Pause at each topic, even when the video seems clear.
  • Typing out the captions. A transcript pasted into notes is the word-for-word problem at full speed. Use captions to catch a term, then write the point yourself.
  • Notes with no times. Without time stamps, checking one point means scrubbing through the whole video. Write the time beside every note.
  • Too fast to follow. In one study, up to 2x cost little and faster than that cost more. Slow down when the material is dense or new.
  • Rewatching instead of testing. Watching the whole video again feels like review. Answer the questions first, then rewatch only the chunks you missed.

06Research

What research has measured

Breaking a lesson into segments

Shown that people learn better from multimedia lessons presented in segments than from one continuous presentation, on both retention and transfer.

The numbers and sources
Effect
A meta-analysis of 56 investigations with 88 comparisons found small to medium effects of segmenting on retention and on transfer. Segmenting also lowered overall cognitive load and increased learning time. These effects held when the system set the pace of the segments, as well as when learners did. Learners with high prior knowledge gained more on retention than learners with little [2]. In the earlier lightning study, learner-paced segments improved transfer but not retention [1].
Population
Learners in the studies pooled in [2]. The abstract does not give a total. Students in two experiments in [1].
Caveats
Most studies used short multimedia lessons such as narrated animations, not hour-long lectures. A pause the viewer chooses is one kind of segment. None of these studies tested writing notes during the pauses.

Quizzing between parts of a lecture

Shown that testing on earlier material helps people learn what comes next. In one set of experiments, quizzes between lecture segments cut mind wandering and raised note-taking.

The numbers and sources
Effect
In the second of two experiments, students quizzed after each segment of a 21-minute statistics lecture reported mind wandering at 19% of probes, against 39% for students who restudied and 41% for students not tested. They added notes on 24% of slides, against 9% and 7%. On the final test, across both experiments, they scored 90%, against 76% and 68% [3]. A meta-analysis found that retrieval reliably improves later learning of new material [7].
Population
Harvard undergraduates, 32 in the first experiment and 48 in the second [3]. Studies pooled in [7].
Caveats
Two small laboratory experiments with one lecture, tested the same day. The researchers wrote the quiz questions. Recalling a chunk at a pause and writing your own question is close to this, but it is not the step that was tested.

Playback speed

One study found lecture videos watched at up to twice normal speed were understood nearly as well as at normal speed, with comprehension falling beyond that.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Raising speed from 1x to 1.5x or 2x cost little on tests given right away or a week later. Performance declined beyond 2x. Watching twice at 2x gave no advantage over watching once at 1x, unless the second viewing came just before the test [6].
Population
Participants watching lecture videos [6]. The abstract does not give their number.
Caveats
The authors note the results may differ for videos with faster speech, harder material or more overlap between what is shown and what is said.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why pause the video instead of writing while it plays?

While it plays, the speaker keeps going and attention splits. A pause gives time to recall the chunk and put it in your own words, and lessons taken in segments are learned better.

What does writing a question for each chunk add?

It turns the notes into a test for later. In one study, short quizzes between parts of a lecture reduced mind wandering and improved learning of the parts that followed.

When do captions help, and when do they get in the way?

They help catch terms and fast speech, and help most in a second language or a new topic. Copying them word for word skips deciding what mattered.

Sources
  1. Mayer RE, Chandler P. When learning is just a click away: Does simple user interaction foster deeper understanding of multimedia messages? Journal of Educational Psychology. 2001;93(2):390-397. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.93.2.390
  2. Rey GD, Beege M, Nebel S, Wirzberger M, Schmitt TH, Schneider S. A meta-analysis of the segmenting effect. Educational Psychology Review. 2019;31(2):389-419. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-018-9456-4
  3. Szpunar KK, Khan NY, Schacter DL. Interpolated memory tests reduce mind wandering and improve learning of online lectures. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 2013;110(16):6313-6317. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1221764110
  4. Gernsbacher MA. Video captions benefit everyone. Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences. 2015;2(1):195-202. https://doi.org/10.1177/2372732215602130
  5. Adesope OO, Nesbit JC. Verbal redundancy in multimedia learning environments: A meta-analysis. Journal of Educational Psychology. 2012;104(1):250-263. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0026147
  6. Murphy DH, Hoover KM, Agadzhanyan K, Kuehn JC, Castel AD. Learning in double time: The effect of lecture video speed on immediate and delayed comprehension. Applied Cognitive Psychology. 2022;36(1):69-82. https://doi.org/10.1002/acp.3899
  7. Chan JCK, Meissner CA, Davis SD. Retrieval potentiates new learning: A theoretical and meta-analytic review. Psychological Bulletin. 2018;144(11):1111-1146. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000166

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII