Studying model texts
Shown that studying model texts improves adolescents' writing a little, while teaching summarization and writing strategies improves it more.
The numbers and sources
- Effect
- A meta-analysis of writing instruction found average effects on writing quality of 0.25 for studying models, 0.50 for sentence combining, 0.82 for summarization and 0.82 for strategy instruction. Grammar instruction had a negative effect (-0.32) [2].
- Population
- Students in grades 4 to 12, in 123 documents yielding 154 effect sizes [2].
- Caveats
- Studying models in these studies meant reading and analyzing good examples. Franklin's rebuild and compare is a more active form, and no study here tested it.