03 / 10Notes

Brief it, then outline it

A long email thread lands with forty replies. A contract runs to thirty pages. A team spends an hour in a meeting, and someone has to say what was decided. Each time the job is the same. Find the few facts that matter, the question in dispute, the answer, and the reason for it. Then do that across many of them, until a whole subject fits on a few pages. Law students do this from their first week. They read appellate decisions that run for pages and reduce each one to a brief. Before exams they fold the briefs and the lectures into a single outline of the course. The brief compresses one case. The outline compresses a semester. Both come down to a question you can ask of any long document: what here would change the answer?

In five minutesTake one long email thread from this week. On a card, write four lines: what happened, the open question as yes or no, what was decided, and why.

Method · Case brief and course outline  /  Skill · Compress  /  Law

↺From last time · The Cornell page

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why leave the cue column empty during the lecture?

Writing the questions later forces a second pass through the notes within a day, while memory is fresh. Deciding what each part was about is where much of the work happens.

Why cover the notes and answer the questions instead of rereading?

Answering from memory is a test. It shows what you actually know and makes it stronger. Rereading feels easier and tells you little about what you can recall.

What makes a good cue question?

One you have to think to answer: why, how, what happens if. A single word with a question mark asks nothing.

01Where it comes from

In 1870 Christopher Columbus Langdell took up a professorship at Harvard Law School and became its dean. He taught contracts from a book of court decisions he chose himself, published in 1871 as A Selection of Cases on the Law of Contracts [1]. His preface argued that law could be learned effectively only through cases, and that most reported cases were useless for study. Students read the decisions before class, and class time went to questioning them about the reasoning. This became known as the case method, and it spread through American law schools. Students prepared by writing a short summary of each case, called a brief. Many law schools teach IRAC for exam answers: issue, rule, application, conclusion. The end-of-term outline is a student tradition more than one person's invention. We found no controlled study of case briefing itself.

Also called Case briefing, IRAC, law school outline.

Most cases are not worth the time

But the cases which are useful and necessary for this purpose at the present day bear an exceedingly small proportion to all that have been reported. The vast majority are useless, and worse than useless, for any purpose of systematic study.

Christopher Columbus Langdell, A Selection of Cases on the Law of Contracts Preface to the first edition, dated October 1, 1871, page viii, as reprinted in the second edition (1879)

Langdell is explaining how he chose the cases for his book. He writes that law consists of principles, each grown slowly through a series of decisions. Most decisions add nothing to that growth. He adds that "the number of fundamental legal doctrines is much less than is commonly supposed." The casebook was itself an act of compression. The brief and the outline ask a student to repeat it, first case by case, then course by course.

Read it in full

02The method

Case brief and course outline

  1. Read the whole case once without writing. Then put the case name, court and year at the top of a page.
  2. Facts. In three or four lines, what happened between the parties. Keep only the facts the court relied on.
  3. Procedural history. Who sued whom, what the lower courts decided, and who appealed.
  4. Issue. The legal question the court answered, written as a yes-or-no question.
  5. Holding and rule. The court's answer in one sentence, and the rule it applied in another.
  6. Reasoning. Why the court decided as it did, in three to five lines. Add any dissent in one line.
  7. Outline. At the end of each unit, merge your briefs and lecture notes under topic headings. Keep each rule and one case that shows it. Cut the rest.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on Hadley v. Baxendale, Court of Exchequer, 1854, a leading English case on damages for breach of contract, from the report in volume 9 of the Exchequer Reports, pages 341 to 356

Name and date

  • Hadley v. Baxendale, 9 Exch. 341. Court of Exchequer, February 1854. Judgment by Alderson, B.

Facts: what happened

  • Hadley and a partner run the City Steam-Mills in Gloucester. The crank shaft of the steam engine breaks and the mill stops.
  • Joyce & Co. of Greenwich will make a new shaft but need the broken one as a pattern.
  • Hadley's servant takes it to Pickford & Co., carriers (Baxendale and others). Pays £2 4s. Told: in by noon, delivered next day.
  • Delivery delayed by neglect. Mill idle several extra days. Hadley sues for lost profits.
  • So far: carrier paid £25 into court. Jury gave £25 more. Carrier asks for a new trial: damages too remote.

Question: what had to be decided

  • Does a carrier who delivers late owe the sender's lost profits, when nothing told the carrier the profits hung on the delivery?

Rule: what decided it

  • Damages are those "arising naturally, i.e., according to the usual course of things, from such breach of contract itself, or such as may reasonably be supposed to have been in the contemplation of both parties, at the time they made the contract, as the probable result of the breach of it."

Reasoning: why

  • All the carrier knew: a broken mill shaft, sent by millers.
  • Most millers sending a shaft away would lose nothing from a delay. They might have a spare, or the mill might be down for other reasons.
  • The special circumstances were "never communicated" to the carrier.
  • Known risks can be priced into the contract. Unknown ones can't.

Result

  • New trial. The jury is to leave the lost profits out entirely.

My take

  • The report says the clerk was told the mill was stopped. Why didn't that count? Counsel for the carrier argued a notice to a clerk could not make a special contract. Ask in class.

04Try it · 40 minutes

For a class

Pick one case from a casebook, or any long textbook example with a problem and a resolution. Brief it on one page in 20 minutes using the six headings. Then take the briefs from one unit and write a one-page outline: topic headings, the rule under each, one case per rule. Whatever does not fit on the page gets cut.

For work and life

Brief a long email thread, a contract or a meeting. Facts: what happened. History: what has already been tried or decided. Issue: the open question, as yes or no. Holding: what was decided, or what you recommend. Reasoning: why, in three lines. At the end of a month, merge the briefs into a one-page outline of the project.

The blank page for this is in the Notes workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Copying the court's words. A brief made of quotations postpones the decision about what mattered. Write each part in your own words. Keep only the rule verbatim.
  • Too many facts. If a fact could change and the result would stay the same, cut it.
  • Outlining too late. An outline started the week before exams turns into a copying job. Add to it at the end of every unit.
  • Using someone else's outline. A borrowed outline helps with review. It skips the deciding, and the deciding is where your own outline pays off.

06Research

What research has measured

Writing your own outline

Shown to help memory and comprehension when readers outline a text themselves, and to help memory when an instructor provides the outline.

The numbers and sources
Effect
A meta-analysis found that students who outlined while reading did better than students who did not, on memory tests, comprehension tests and writing tasks, with moderate effects on each. Outlines provided by an instructor helped memory about as much, and comprehension less [2].
Population
Students learning from text, in the experiments pooled in [2].
Caveats
These studies outline a single text, not a semester of cases. Learner-made and instructor-made outlines were each compared with no outline. They were not compared with each other [2].

Revising notes after the lecture

One study found revising lecture notes helped somewhat more than recopying them, and revising during pauses helped more than revising after.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Students who revised their notes recorded more additional notes and scored somewhat higher on questions about relationships than students who recopied them. Revising during pauses in the lecture beat one equal pause at the end, on both notes and test scores. Working with a partner led to more original notes [3].
Population
Participants in two experiments. The abstract does not give their number [3].
Caveats
One research group and short lectures. The authors call the revision effect and the partner effect modest [3].

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

What makes a fact worth keeping in a brief?

The result depends on it. If a fact could change and the outcome would stay the same, cut it.

Why write the issue as a yes-or-no question?

It forces you to find the exact point in dispute. A yes-or-no question has one answer, the holding, and the reasoning then has to explain it.

Why add to the outline at the end of each unit instead of before the exam?

Merging a few fresh briefs keeps each step small, and the deciding stays yours. An outline started the week before exams turns into copying.

Sources
  1. Langdell CC. A Selection of Cases on the Law of Contracts, with a Summary of the Topics Covered by the Cases. 2nd ed. Little, Brown, and Company; 1879 (first edition 1871). https://archive.org/details/cu31924018826713
  2. Ponce HR, Mayer RE, Méndez EE. Effects of learner-generated outlining and instructor-provided outlining on learning from text: A meta-analysis. Educational Research Review. 2023;39:100538. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2023.100538
  3. Luo L, Kiewra KA, Samuelson L. Revising lecture notes: How revision, pauses, and partners affect note taking and achievement. Instructional Science. 2016;44(1):45-67. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11251-016-9370-4

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII