Debriefs and performance
Shown that structured debriefs after training or work improve later performance, by about a quarter on average in one review.
The numbers and sources
- Effect
- Debriefs improved effectiveness over control groups by about 25% (d = .67), with similar effects for teams and individuals, in simulated and real settings, and in medical and other samples [1]. A later meta-analysis found d = 0.79. Reviews aligned to the individual or the team, and reviews using objective records of performance, worked better [3].
- Population
- 2,136 participants in 46 samples [1]. 915 teams and 3,499 individuals in 61 studies [3].
- Caveats
- Most studies tested debriefs in training, in the military, medicine and similar settings. One person's review of their own week is a smaller cousin of these, and was not tested itself. The later analysis corrected for sampling error only [3].