01 / 08Systems

From notes to a system

A semester of notes from one class can sit in a binder and never touch the notes from another. A year of meeting notes at work can sit in a folder the same way. Each page is fine on its own. Nothing happens between them. Link two notes and that changes. A note on supply and demand points to a note on why the store ran out of bread. A note from a project review points to one from last spring's launch. The set starts to answer questions that no single page answers. It now has parts, connections and a purpose. Those three things make a system. This course starts with notes, a system small enough to build in an afternoon.

In five minutesPick three notes from this week, from different classes or meetings. On each, write one line naming another of the three and how they connect: "causes", "is an example of" or "contradicts".

Method · Linked notes as a system  /  Skill · Connect  /  Writing · Science

01Where it comes from

The Notes course teaches the slip box of Niklas Luhmann, the German sociologist. In 1981 he published a short essay in German on communicating with slip boxes [1]. He describes the box as a partner in thinking. Fixed numbers let a new note branch off any old one. Cross-references let one note sit in many contexts without being copied. A keyword index gives the ways in. He writes that a note with no links is as good as lost. Over years the box grows complex enough to surprise its owner, and a search through its links turns up combinations no one planned. Donella Meadows, in Thinking in Systems (2008), describes any system as three things: elements, the connections between them, and a function or purpose [2]. A linked set of notes has all three. No study has tested a slip box as a system. Concept maps, diagrams of ideas joined by labeled links, have been tested often, and are the closest research [3][4].

Also called Concept map, knowledge map, note network, systematic thinking.

02The method

Linked notes as a system

  1. Gather 15 to 25 notes on one subject or project, from any source.
  2. Write the purpose at the top of a blank page as one question this set should help answer.
  3. Put each idea on its own card or line, one idea each, and give it a number.
  4. Draw a line between every two ideas that connect. Label each line with a short phrase: "causes", "is an example of", "contradicts".
  5. Find the ideas with the most lines and the ones with none. Give each loner a link, or set it aside.
  6. Answer the purpose question in one paragraph by following a path along the lines.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on Chapter 1 of the Enchiridion, about 400 words, as four linked notes

The question this set answers

  • What does chapter 1 ask a reader to do first when something goes wrong?

Note 1

  • One idea, in my own words: Epictetus sorts everything into two kinds. Our own acts are in our power: opinion, desire, aversion. Body, property, reputation and office are not.
  • Links to notes: 2 (is the cause behind), 3 (is the test used in)
  • Source: Enchiridion 1, Long

Note 2

  • One idea, in my own words: Treating what belongs to others as your own leads to being hindered, lamenting, and blaming gods and people.
  • Links to notes: 1 (follows from), 4 (is the cost that 4 avoids)
  • Source: Enchiridion 1, Long

Note 3

  • One idea, in my own words: Faced with a harsh appearance, ask first whether it is in your power. If not, be ready to say it does not concern you.
  • Links to notes: 1 (applies), 2 (is the way out of)
  • Source: Enchiridion 1, Long

Note 4

  • One idea, in my own words: Great aims take more than a small effort. Some things get left alone entirely and some get put off.
  • Links to notes: 2 (explains why chasing everything fails), 9 (is an example of: my note on turning down a second project at work)
  • Source: Enchiridion 1, Long

Following the links

  • 3, then 1, then 2: when something goes wrong, sort it first. If it is not mine to control, treating it as mine is what brings the blame and the lament.
The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 30 minutes

For a class

Take this week's notes from one class. Pick 12 ideas and write each on a numbered card or line. In 15 minutes, draw every link you can see and label each with a short phrase. Circle the two ideas with the most links. Then write a paragraph answering a likely exam question by following the links out from those two. About 30 minutes.

For work and life

Take a month of notes on one project or skill: meetings, reading, your own jottings. Write the question the project most needs answered at the top of a page. Turn 10 to 15 notes into numbered single ideas and join them with labeled lines. Find the idea nothing links to and decide where it belongs. Write a one-paragraph answer by following the links.

The blank page for this is in the Systems workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • A map of everything. Without a purpose question, every note links to every other and the map says nothing. Name the question first, and keep the links that help answer it.
  • Unlabeled lines. A bare line says only that two ideas relate. A labeled line says how. Deciding the how is where the learning happens.
  • Recopying in place of connecting. Rewriting notes neatly feels productive and adds no links. Spend the time deciding how two ideas relate.
  • Waiting for a full collection. A dozen linked notes already show a structure. Start small and add.

06Research

What research has measured

Mapping ideas and their links

Shown that building or studying concept maps, diagrams of ideas joined by labeled links, helps students remember material. This is related to linked notes, not a test of them.

The numbers and sources
Effect
A meta-analysis of 67 effect sizes from 55 studies found concept maps associated with better knowledge retention, with effects from small to large depending on how the maps were used [3]. An update pooling 142 effect sizes found a moderate overall effect, g = 0.58. Creating maps helped more (g = 0.72) than studying ready-made ones (g = 0.43) [4].
Population
5,818 participants in the first review and 11,814 in the update, from grade 4 to postsecondary, in science, psychology, statistics, nursing and other subjects [3][4].
Caveats
Effects varied widely between studies [3]. A concept map is usually drawn for one lesson or test and then set aside. A slip box is kept for years. No study here tested linked notes kept over time.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

What turns a pile of notes into a system?

Three things: the notes as parts, the links between them, and a purpose question they help answer. Without the purpose, links multiply and say nothing.

Why label a link instead of just drawing a line?

A bare line says two ideas relate. A label says how: causes, is an example of, contradicts. Choosing the label is a decision about the relationship, and that decision is what gets learned.

What does a note with no links tell you?

Either its link has not been found yet, or it does not serve this question. Give it a link or set it aside. An unlinked note is rarely found again.

Sources
  1. Luhmann N. Kommunikation mit Zettelkästen: Ein Erfahrungsbericht. In: Baier H, Kepplinger HM, Reumann K, eds. Öffentliche Meinung und sozialer Wandel / Public Opinion and Social Change. Westdeutscher Verlag; 1981:222-228. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-322-87749-9_19
  2. Meadows DH. Thinking in Systems: A Primer. Wright D, ed. Chelsea Green; 2008. first edition
  3. Nesbit JC, Adesope OO. Learning with concept and knowledge maps: A meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research. 2006;76(3):413-448. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543076003413
  4. Schroeder NL, Nesbit JC, Anguiano CJ, Adesope OO. Studying and constructing concept maps: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychology Review. 2018;30(2):431-455. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-017-9403-9

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII