02 / 09Study

Why rereading feels like learning

The chapter is due Thursday. On Wednesday night it gets read once, then again with a highlighter. By the second pass the sentences feel familiar. The terms look right. Each paragraph says what it seemed it would say. Then the exam asks for the third step of a process, or a definition in plain words, and the page that felt so clear does not come back. The same thing happens at work with a manual, a policy update, or a training video watched twice. From the inside, familiar and remembered feel alike. They are different things. Rereading builds the first. This lesson is about telling them apart, and about one small change that does it: closing the book and trying to say it.

In five minutesTonight, read one page of something you need to learn. Turn it face down and write every point you remember for three minutes. Then check, and circle what you missed.

Method · Read, recite, review  /  Skill · Recall  /  Research psychology

↺From last time · Getting started

Answer these from memory before you start. Tap to check.

Why does a small, specific first task help with starting?

Unpleasant tasks are the ones people put off most, and tasks that need many decisions wait too. A small, concrete first step is less unpleasant, and it leaves no decision about where to begin.

What is known, and what is unsettled, about phones and studying?

Using a phone or laptop for other things while studying lowers learning. Whether a phone merely lying nearby costs attention is unsettled. One study found it did, and later studies found little or no effect.

Why let a timer decide when to break?

In one study, students on fixed breaks felt less tired and more focused than students who chose their own breaks, and finished as much in less time.

01Where it comes from

Rereading is the most common way students study, by their own account [1]. Psychologists call the trap an illusion of competence. A page that reads smoothly the second time feels learned, and that feeling is a poor guide to what will be there next week [1][2]. In 1994 Robert Bjork, a psychologist at UCLA, named the other side "desirable difficulties": ways of studying that feel slower and harder in the moment and leave more behind [3][4]. The fix is old. Francis Robinson's SQ3R, from his book Effective Study (1946), already ended in recite and review [5]. In 2009 Mark McDaniel and colleagues tested a stripped-down version, read, recite, review, against rereading [6]. Rereading still has some use. A 2013 review of ten study techniques rated it low utility, which is not the same as none [7].

Also called 3R, illusion of competence, fluency illusion, rereading.

02The method

Read, recite, review

  1. Read one section once, at your normal pace. Mark nothing yet.
  2. Close the book, or turn the page face down.
  3. Recite. Say or write everything you remember, in your own words, for two to five minutes. Leave a blank where nothing comes.
  4. Review. Open the book and check what you said against it. Mark what was missing or wrong.
  5. Reread only the parts you missed. Then recite those parts once more.
  6. Move on to the next section and repeat.

03An example

What it looks like done

Worked on Chapter 1 of the Enchiridion, about 400 words, read once, then recited from memory and checked

Guess, before writing

  • After one careful read: I could write about 80% of it.

Recited from memory

  • Some things are up to us and some are not.
  • Up to us: our opinions, what we want, what we avoid.
  • Not up to us: the body, money, reputation, jobs.
  • Treat what isn't yours as yours and you get upset and blame people.
  • Something about great aims needing more than a small effort?
  • (blank: the end of the chapter)

Checked against the text

  • Missed: "movement towards a thing" in the first list, and the summary, "whatever are our acts."
  • Wrong word: "money" is property. "Jobs" is offices, public positions.
  • Missed: what is in our power is "by nature free." The rest is "weak, slavish," in the power of others.
  • Missed the promise: claim only what is yours and no one can compel or hinder you, and "you will have no enemy."
  • Missed the ending entirely: say to every harsh appearance, "You are an appearance," then ask whether it is in our power.
  • About half came back, not 80%.

Recited again, the missed parts only

  • In our power: opinion, movement toward a thing, desire, aversion. Free by nature.
  • Not in our power: body, property, reputation, offices. In others' hands.
  • Claim only your own, and no one can hinder you.
  • A harsh appearance: call it an appearance, then ask whether it is in our power. If not, it does not concern me.
The text: The Enchiridion, Chapter 1

04Try it · 20 minutes

For a class

Take about two pages of your next assigned reading. Read them once. Close the book and guess what share of it you could write down. Then write for five minutes, from memory. Open the book, check, and circle what you left out. Compare your guess with what the page shows. If there is no reading due, use the second chapter of Seneca's On the Shortness of Life.

Open it in the reader: On the Shortness of Life and Other Dialogues, On the Shortness of Life, II

For work and life

Pick a document you will need to act on this week: a policy change, a project brief, the manual for a new tool. Read it once. Close it and write, from memory, the five points a colleague would need from it. Check against the document. The points you missed are the only ones to read again. About 15 minutes.

The blank page for this is in the Study workbook.

05Where it goes wrong

  • Reciting with the page in view. One glance at the text turns recall back into reading. Close the book or the laptop before you start.
  • Highlighting as the second pass. Highlighting feels active, and it is still reading. The 2013 review rated it low utility too. Recite first, and mark afterward.
  • Judging by how it feels. The second read usually feels easier, whether or not anything stuck. Judge by what you could write with the book shut.
  • Rereading straight away. A second read right after the first helped on a test that day. Two days later the advantage was gone. When a reread is worth doing, leave days between.
  • Skipping the check. Reciting without looking afterward can lock in a wrong version. Open the book every time.

06Research

What research has measured

Rereading compared with recalling

Shown that recalling studied material beats rereading it on tests days or weeks later, though rereading can come out ahead on a test minutes later.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Students who read a short passage four times recalled 83% of it five minutes later, against 71% for students who read it once and recalled it three times. A week later the order reversed, 40% against 61% [8]. Meta-analyses put the advantage of practice tests over restudying at g = 0.50 across 159 effect sizes [9] and g = 0.51 in a second review [10]. Read, recite, review improved free recall over rereading, immediately and a week later [6].
Population
180 undergraduates in the second experiment of [8]. 61 studies in [9]. 272 effect sizes from 15,427 participants in [10]. College students in two experiments in [6].
Caveats
Most studies use college students and short texts or word lists, and results varied widely between studies [9]. Rereading is not worthless. Rereading after a week's gap helped on a test two days later [11], and the 2013 review rated it low utility, which still means some [7].

How sure rereading makes people

Shown that repeated reading raises confidence more than it raises later recall, so the feeling of knowing can point the wrong way.

The numbers and sources
Effect
Students who read a passage four times predicted they would remember it better a week later than students who had been tested on it. They remembered the least [8]. In a study of painting styles, 78% of participants did better when examples were mixed, and 78% said blocked study was as good or better [12]. A review describes people judging their learning by how fluent the material feels in the moment [2].
Population
180 undergraduates [8]. 120 undergraduates in the first painting experiment [12]. [2] is a narrative review.
Caveats
Confidence was measured with single ratings or questionnaires. The painting study concerns telling categories apart, a different task from learning a chapter [12]. The review collects many studies without pooling them in a meta-analysis [2].

What students report doing

One survey found most college students reread as their main way of studying, and few tested themselves.

The numbers and sources
Effect
84% listed rereading notes or the textbook, and 55% named it their top strategy. 11% reported practicing recall, and 1% named it first. Asked what they would do after reading a chapter once, 57% chose to reread it and 18% chose to test themselves [1].
Population
177 college students at one university [1].
Caveats
Self-report from one campus. It describes habits and does not test which habit works.

07Check yourself

Answer from memory first. The next lesson asks these again.

Why does a second read feel like learning when it may not be?

The page is familiar, so it reads smoothly, and smooth reading feels like knowing. Familiar and remembered are different things. Only recall with the book shut shows which one you have.

Why recite before checking, instead of checking as you go?

Recall with the page out of sight is the practice that makes material last. A glance turns it back into reading. The check afterward catches gaps and errors so a wrong version doesn't stick.

When can rereading still help?

After a gap of days, and on the parts you missed. A second read straight after the first helped on a test that day, and the advantage was gone two days later.

Sources
  1. Karpicke JD, Butler AC, Roediger HL III. Metacognitive strategies in student learning: Do students practise retrieval when they study on their own? Memory. 2009;17(4):471-479. https://doi.org/10.1080/09658210802647009
  2. Bjork RA, Dunlosky J, Kornell N. Self-regulated learning: Beliefs, techniques, and illusions. Annual Review of Psychology. 2013;64:417-444. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-113011-143823
  3. Bjork RA. Memory and metamemory considerations in the training of human beings. In: Metcalfe J, Shimamura AP, eds. Metacognition: Knowing about Knowing. MIT Press; 1994:185-205. MIT Press, 1994
  4. Soderstrom NC, Bjork RA. Learning versus performance: An integrative review. Perspectives on Psychological Science. 2015;10(2):176-199. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691615569000
  5. Robinson FP. Effective Study. Harper & Brothers; 1946. Harper & Brothers, first edition, 1946
  6. McDaniel MA, Howard DC, Einstein GO. The read-recite-review study strategy: Effective and portable. Psychological Science. 2009;20(4):516-522. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2009.02325.x
  7. Dunlosky J, Rawson KA, Marsh EJ, Nathan MJ, Willingham DT. Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques: Promising directions from cognitive and educational psychology. Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 2013;14(1):4-58. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100612453266
  8. Roediger HL III, Karpicke JD. Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science. 2006;17(3):249-255. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2006.01693.x
  9. Rowland CA. The effect of testing versus restudy on retention: A meta-analytic review of the testing effect. Psychological Bulletin. 2014;140(6):1432-1463. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0037559
  10. Adesope OO, Trevisan DA, Sundararajan N. Rethinking the use of tests: A meta-analysis of practice testing. Review of Educational Research. 2017;87(3):659-701. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654316689306
  11. Rawson KA, Kintsch W. Rereading effects depend on time of test. Journal of Educational Psychology. 2005;97(1):70-80. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-0663.97.1.70
  12. Kornell N, Bjork RA. Learning concepts and categories: Is spacing the "enemy of induction"? Psychological Science. 2008;19(6):585-592. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02127.x

MVIII puts the day in front of you each morning. Get MVIII