Rereading compared with recalling
Shown that recalling studied material beats rereading it on tests days or weeks later, though rereading can come out ahead on a test minutes later.
The numbers and sources
- Effect
- Students who read a short passage four times recalled 83% of it five minutes later, against 71% for students who read it once and recalled it three times. A week later the order reversed, 40% against 61% [8]. Meta-analyses put the advantage of practice tests over restudying at g = 0.50 across 159 effect sizes [9] and g = 0.51 in a second review [10]. Read, recite, review improved free recall over rereading, immediately and a week later [6].
- Population
- 180 undergraduates in the second experiment of [8]. 61 studies in [9]. 272 effect sizes from 15,427 participants in [10]. College students in two experiments in [6].
- Caveats
- Most studies use college students and short texts or word lists, and results varied widely between studies [9]. Rereading is not worthless. Rereading after a week's gap helped on a test two days later [11], and the 2013 review rated it low utility, which still means some [7].